At noon today, our editorial page shared a news report concerning live birds packed tightly into plastic beverage bottles to be smuggled across customs borders.
Shortly after, a gentleman named Mr. Kuo reposted the piece, attaching a link to a blogger’s essay that argued at length that "**abusing cats is rational and praiseworthy**". In the comments section of that post, seventy to eighty comments piled up, with the vast majority vocalizing enthusiastic agreement.
The scene felt like an inmate in a penitentiary pontificating on his grand criminal philosophies while fellow convicts cheer in chorus.
Not content with merely sharing that post, Mr. Kuo also dropped a link on our fan page to an exposé on factory chicken farming. Seeing it as an off-topic diversion, I initially deleted it. On reflection, however, such viewpoints deserve thoughtful critique. Hence, I decided to write this brief commentary to share a perspective.
Deducing from the two links Mr. Kuo left behind, he likely wanted to suggest that sharing animal welfare news is symptomatic of "**a psychological affliction of pointless moral posturing**". Frankly, I have little patience for muddled rhetoric from those hiding behind cryptic links to project an aura of profound contrarian wisdom.
In reality, certain foundational principles anchor our dignity as human beings, and rationality in our coexistence with the natural world is one of them.
Apart from pure white moral truth and pitch-black malice, human society exists mostly across ambiguous shades of gray.
For instance, I firmly believe that in wild natural environments, leaving behind any trash whatsoever is intolerable; I frequently pack out litter while hiking. Yet in a paid, enclosed parking structure, I can rationalize someone leaving rubbish behind, recognizing that littering often stems from management failing to provide adequate waste receptacles (unless the parking contract explicitly stipulates that fees exclude facility cleaning)—an everyday example I often cite to illustrate contextual nuance.
Some friends associate me reflexively with environmentalism and wildlife conservation. Yet I have never labeled myself an environmentalist or conservationist. I merely pursue a pragmatic form of ecological rationality (in truth, I am more inclined to frown at the sensationalist tactics of groups like Greenpeace than applaud them).
Nevertheless, stuffing live birds into sealed plastic bottles with exorbitant mortality rates purely for smuggling profit, or tormenting domestic cats for personal amusement, represents unadulterated foolishness in my book.
Conversely, take dog meat consumption in traditional South Korean cuisine. Dogs are not an endangered species teetering on the brink of extinction like blue whales. Therefore, while I oppose commercial whaling by Japanese or South Korean fleets, I recognize the cultural rationality of South Koreans consuming dog meat. But that never confers a license for animal abuse, because cruelty itself lacks biological rationality: no predator in the animal kingdom torments prey purely for the pleasure of cruelty.
To evaluate any issue fairly, one cannot judge solely from a single vantage point; actions often carry distinct rationales across different cultural and social frameworks.
Through continuous dialogue, friction, and integration, I believe these diverse shades of gray converge toward cohesive societal norms, forging refined collective values.
For example, international conventions have established rigorous regulatory protocols for the global import and export of avian species. Transporting exotic birds through these certified procedures represents a structured, rational compromise between human possessiveness and conservation. When someone deliberately sidesteps established safety protocols with fatal cruelty, their actions are devoid of rationality.
If we approach contentious issues with greater depth, broader perspective, and genuine respect for rationality—rather than succumbing to self-indulgent sentimentality or reactive populism—many debates in modern life would dissolve into clear consensus.
Just look at nuclear power (the floor is now open for heated debate 💀).
References
Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights
Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.
Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.
Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account




Comments