Newly appointed Minister of Education Wu Maw-kuen faced intense public controversy after records revealed he incorporated a private enterprise in California, allegedly transferring patents developed at National Dong Hwa University (NDHU) to file under the private company’s name. When questioned, Wu defended the move as an “expedient procedural necessity” to obtain international patent protection.
Is Wu’s claim that incorporating in the US was an expedient necessity to file patents legally sound?
The clear answer is: Completely False.
In standard patent practice, an inventor or academic institution simply commissions a domestic patent and intellectual property firm. The domestic firm coordinates with corresponding associate patent attorneys in the United States to file foreign dockets on behalf of the university. There is never any legal necessity for an inventor to travel overseas and incorporate a personal LLC simply to file a patent application.
Bypassing the university system to file under a private company name inevitably fuels suspicions regarding whether intellectual property belonging to the university (as the institutional patentee) was misappropriated into private corporate hands.
Academic inventions in the Republic of China are routinely managed through university Innovation and Incubation Centers and Technology Transfer Offices, operating under clear institutional bylaws. Why Wu bypassed established NDHU protocols to register a private company in the US remains the central question requiring transparent explanation.
Wu asserted that if the PCT patent were granted, the benefits would eventually revert to the university. Yet Dong Hwa University administrators stated they only learned of the matter through news reports, confirming that no prior notification or formal assignment agreements existed.
Wu further claimed: “To maximize the invention’s utility, I sought a ‘world patent’ covering multiple countries. Because public-sector applications are procedurally cumbersome, I entrusted a Taiwanese scientist with US citizenship to apply, and forming a US company was necessary to file for a world patent.”
This assertion is equally flawed on fundamental patent law grounds:
First, there is no such legal instrument as a “World Patent”. Patent rights are strictly governed by the principle of territoriality: patents granted by a national patent office provide legal exclusivity solely within that country’s sovereign jurisdiction. No single international application automatically grants universal worldwide patent protection.
What exists instead is the Patent Cooperation Treaty (PCT) administered by the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO). The PCT allows nationals or residents of contracting states to file a single international application in the International Phase, establishing an international priority date. Following preliminary search and examination, the applicant must enter the National Phase within 30 months across individual target nations, paying national fees and undergoing separate domestic substantive examinations.
While the Republic of China is not a WIPO member state, Taiwanese universities and entities routinely file PCT applications via reciprocal agreements, through US associate firms, or under the World Trade Organization (WTO) intellectual property reciprocity framework. Furthermore, filing a PCT application in the US does not require incorporating a company; having a US citizen or green-card holder listed as an inventor or co-applicant suffices.
Establishing an offshore shell company to handle public university IP without institutional authorization was neither legally necessary nor procedurally standard, creating an ethical controversy that warrants full public transparency.
Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights
Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.
Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.
Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account




Comments