A trending wave of discussions on Facebook recently caught my attention: one crowd keeps dismissing Mainland China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), another is reminiscing about the late variety show legend Chu Ke-liang, and a third group is scolding the first two for wasting their breath. Mourning the passing of an entertainment icon is understandable, but what about the Belt and Road?

Many netizens label the Belt and Road as a “worthless vanity project,” claiming its annual freight volume won’t even equal a single voyage of a container mega-ship, while numerous anti-China commentators churn out satirical articles and mocking cartoons.

Watching these waves of criticism leaves me utterly puzzled. Why spend so much time and energy obsessing over an initiative that we cannot even join? To put it bluntly: what does it have to do with you?

Back during the ECFA Cross-Strait Service Trade Agreement controversy, at least that was a pact our own authorities were preparing to enter. But Mainland China’s Belt and Road Initiative? We aren’t being invited to either table anyway, yet people on the island remain engrossed in self-absorbed mockery.

The blend of performative resistance and disdain echoing across social media feeds is painful to witness—what fragile self-comfort. Fortunately, people still have cultural-creative industries and “little everyday pleasures” to satisfy their emotional cravings.

Beyond the ECFA trade pact and the Belt and Road, remember the US-led TPP that President Tsai heavily promoted, which thrilled many in Taiwan who fantasized about joining hands with the US and Japan to snub Mainland China?

Yet how many realize that being unable to join the TPP might actually have been a blessing in disguise? Otherwise, many of Taiwan’s pillar small-and-medium enterprises would likely have suffered severely, and the domestic market might have contracted even faster—an outcome that, without exaggeration, could have felt as economically devastating as the Treaty of Shimonoseki that the Qing dynasty was forced to sign with Japan.

The crux of the Belt and Road isn’t about how many freight containers a single train car can haul, nor whether its direct economic substitution appears lucrative on paper today. You need to consider what Mainland China has been doing across Southeast Asia and Africa in recent years, recall the Cold War space race between the US and the Soviets, or think of the Antarctic—efforts that are grueling and unrewarding at first glance, yet treated as strategic necessities by major powers. Only then can you begin to glimpse the true scope of Beijing’s ambitions.

Have you ever witnessed an integrated macro-complex that weaves together logistics, transportation, culture, global influence, and financial flows—the decisive pillars of modern global powers? The ambition is laid bare in broad daylight, unfolding step by deliberate step.

The rail transport logistics that netizens expend so much energy nitpicking is merely a minor cornerstone in a vast grand blueprint. Does that mean Mainland China is already at peak dominance? Far from it. The Belt and Road is simply a foundational mechanism engineered toward a much larger goal; you could say Mainland China is only just getting started. And this entire game board was set in motion by Xi Jinping as early as 2007.

What struck me most was during the Service Trade Agreement debate, a friend told me he didn’t oppose the pact in principle, but couldn’t see any coherent economic roadmap from our government. When I asked him about the Belt and Road recently, he reiterated that any infrastructure lacking a complete public blueprint is “garbage.” In reality, both are matters of scale: the former was a pressing necessity, the latter an expansive strategic desire.

The bottom line is: just because you cannot perceive the full picture does not mean dozens of top-tier research institutes haven’t meticulously mapped out a massive long-term master plan. When my friend asked me to analyze the Belt and Road, I could only outline its broad contours; as for grasping every core strategic layer, my grasp—and anyone’s outside top policy circles—is modest at best. Yet he scoffed at it anyway. It made me sorely tempted to offer him an old idiom: “looking at the sky from the bottom of a well.”

In summary, when confronted with macro strategies beyond our immediate grasp, rather than desperately hunting for superficial flaws to disparage, it is far more worthwhile to understand the mindset and ambition driving others forward.

Regrettably, current Facebook discourse fixates almost entirely on whether freight train volumes trail maritime shipping, whether varying railway gauges require changing bogies, or which countries have friction with the initiative—minor hurdles common to any megaproject. Is this truly the best level of insight our public discourse has to offer?

For those interested in exploring how Mainland China’s Belt and Road Initiative is reshaping the world, the following reading list is recommended:

  • The Belt and Road Initiative: China’s Solution for Win-Win Cooperation
  • Why the TPP Collapsed: Global Think Tanks on TPP, Belt and Road, and AIIB
  • The Belt and Road: Regional Reciprocity and Mutual Benefit Under Global Dual Circulation
✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account