Recently there has been a lot of noise surrounding a certain startup scandal. Since I happened to be traveling in Japan, I wasn’t following it closely. The only related document I read was the official statement released by the “good guy” manufacturer. Frankly, although the statement merely laid out a simple chronological progression and the legal rights they held (for instance, the patent filing timeline), it was enough to reveal just how much shady business was brewing behind the scenes.

Early this morning, an industry friend forwarded an online post. After reading it, I realized it strongly correlated with many details I understood from the manufacturer’s statement, so I’m reposting it here for your reference. Although the article uses the “Big Bad Wolf” as an analogy and claims he was once a senior corporate executive, this wolf managed to stumble over fundamental common sense. In essence, he marched straight into a self-made trap. Whether he’s really a big bad wolf or just a noisy little lamb is hard to say (the original author probably borrowed the wolf from Little Red Riding Hood or The Three Little Pigs).

Below is the repost of that online insider post. Feel free to read it if you are interested. If there are any factual inaccuracies, corrections are always welcome.


Browsing news online late at night, I dozed off into a daze, and seemed to have a dream…

In the dream, there was a young woman with a talent for marketing who worked in sales at a company. Feeling the company lacked grand ambition, she decided to branch out on her own. Her former boss supported her, allowing her to sell company products in new online channels, with fairly solid results.

Later, she felt one of her former company’s products had great potential and could sell massively if repackaged. The former boss, having applied for the patent in 2012, had already applied that technology across many company products; however, since this new packaging catered better to consumer tastes, he agreed to launch a crowdfunding campaign on a certain platform.

The project had a target of NT$2 million. The young woman only knew marketing, so all the industrial and structural design work was handled by the company’s staff. The former boss figured that even if the campaign failed, it didn’t matter much—the company would simply gain another product line to sell slowly over time.

Unexpectedly, the young woman’s marketing really hit the mark. The project received widespread acclaim, raising over NT$60 million. At this point, had standard business etiquette been followed—promptly signing supply contracts, expediting manufacturing (paying required overtime, of course), and shipping to consumers—everyone would have walked away happy in a three-way win.

Then, out of nowhere, the Big Bad Wolf appeared.

The Big Bad Wolf used to be a senior executive at a major enterprise and had seen plenty of dirty tactics to squeeze suppliers. For instance:

  1. “Rush order—please prepare materials first, contracts will follow later”: Lock the supplier in. When no one else wants the parts, they have no choice but to supply at a loss.
  2. Pitting two or three suppliers against one another in a circular price squeeze: Telling Supplier A, “Supplier B can do it for 20 million; will you take it for 18 million?” Once accepted, going to Supplier B: “Supplier A offered 18 million; can you take it for 16 million?”

Listening to the Big Bad Wolf, the young woman began betraying the former boss who had always supported her. Calculating that fulfilling the order under these terms would mean deep financial losses, the company decided to pull out. Thinking the company was backed into a corner and would ultimately sell at a loss, the Big Bad Wolf boldly continued demanding physical samples, planning to hand them over to another manufacturer to copy.

Yet the Big Bad Wolf lacked real acumen, failing to realize that both the patents and the proprietary designs were entirely owned by the company—their side held only the right to market under a specific product name. When they previously pushed, claiming “another vendor can do it for 20 million”, the company cheerfully agreed, stating they would merely collect patent licensing royalties; the Big Bad Wolf and the young woman had even agreed at the time. Naturally, after the fact, they claimed that was spoken in anger.

In the end, faced with tied-up capital and the looming pressure of year-end bonuses, the company had no choice but to sell the inventory they had spent fortunes preparing—products they held the full legal right to sell in the first place. Yet the honest boss still didn’t want to hurt the young woman, so he refrained from attacking the crowdfunding campaign.

Instead, sensing things were heading south, the Big Bad Wolf urged the young woman to step forward immediately, playing the victim and lambasting the supplier publicly. Seeing these allegations of unfairness, netizens erupted in fury, condemning the manufacturer as unscrupulous. The bewildered honest manufacturer could only state the bare facts. Unexpectedly, netizens saw through the smoke once the facts emerged, and public sentiment flipped overnight.

Having ridden the wolf too far to dismount, the Big Bad Wolf had no choice but to keep slinging mud at the manufacturer in the media.

And then, I woke up from my dream.

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account