Browsing Facebook recently, I noticed that the ambiance of Neiwan Station—a spot I haven’t visited in ages—has shifted once again. A brand-new row of overhead canopies has been erected along the train platforms. They shield neither wind nor rain, looking neither like functional rain shelters nor legitimate public art, and have drawn blistering condemnation from local cultural historians. Perhaps the serene, tranquil mountain town atmosphere that captivated me over a decade ago is gradually fading into distant memory.
In response, the Taipei Works Section of the Taiwan Railways Administration stated that the installation takes into account the mountain village’s local forestry and mining heritage. The canopy design was meant to evoke “relaxing under a big tree,” while the branching steel structure symbolizes railway culture. Furthermore, integrating glass panels, Hakka floral fabric motifs, and branching lighting was intended to enhance night safety for returning locals, contrasting the steadfast weight of steel against an old mountain township.
Well, claiming it looks “steadfast” is overly modest. For such a cozy little mountain village, this massive steel structure practically recalls the classical quote: "**Suddenly a monstrous creature appeared, uprooting mountains and felling trees—behold, it was a giant toad!**" What is worse, these overbearing canopies completely eclipse the station building itself, degenerating into a preposterous case of putting the cart before the horse.
The real problem after adding the canopies isn’t necessarily the designed steel columns themselves, but that they were forced into an entirely inappropriate space. Neiwan’s already tight-knit, compact landscape was burdened with an intrusive row of dark, heavy steel pillars. Far from opening up spatial depth, it glues the entire visual landscape together into a dense, oppressive clot.
Examining these canopies—dubbed “giant steel nails” by locals—more closely, they evoke an uncanny sense of déjà vu. I feel like I’ve encountered almost identical shelter frameworks on countless domestic travels before.
Frankly speaking, it feels like a contracting team won a public procurement bid, pocketed the budget, recycled an old generic blueprint from their portfolio, tacked on branch-like steel rafters, and slapped the label "**big tree imagery**" onto it. In reality, it feels just like every old street across Taiwan selling the exact same copy-paste souvenirs (stares into the distance).
Now that the public agency has forcefully wedged this steel contraption onto Neiwan Station’s platform, the dilemma has escalated: should they begrudgingly preserve this mismatched eyesore, or squander additional taxpayer funds to dismantle and relocate it? Either way, it poses an awkward headache for the authorities, and it certainly won’t satisfy the majority of the public (setting aside the partisan loyalists who back every administrative move without question).
In my view, they might as well dismantle this steel colonnade into three or four equal sections and donate them to elementary and junior high schools in the mountainous backcountry of Hsinchu as sheltered waiting areas for school children. As for Neiwan Station’s platform, let it return to its airy, tranquil, unburdened state, preserving the authentic charm a mountain town ought to possess. If humans dread getting caught in the rain so much, they might as well imitate Taoyuan Mayor Cheng Wen-tsan by burning massive budgets on cosmetic railway undergrounding projects, or endlessly tweaking line alignments until the Airport MRT line loses its original express efficiency (flips table).
Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights
Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.
Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.
Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account




Comments