Without question, today’s most explosive breaking news was New Party’s Wang Bing-zhong suddenly starting a livestream at 6:00 AM, showing a large detachment of police and Investigation Bureau officers attempting to escort him away from his home. The scene bore an uncanny resemblance to the measures taken during the martial law era by the Kuomintang (KMT) to eliminate communist agents.

Wait, at least back then the Nationalist government acted to defend against external adversaries and prevent Taiwan from falling to communist takeover. Today, the Tsai administration appears to be acting to consolidate power—plainly playing underhanded politics from within.

Lee Ming-che went to the Chinese mainland to advocate for democracy and ended up imprisoned by the Chinese Communist Party.

Wang Bing-zhong, here in Taiwan… well, I am still not sure what he was capable of doing, but he was hauled away by the Investigation Bureau.

They even hauled away Wang Bing-zhong’s father as well!? Are they planning to open two separate interrogation rooms to orchestrate a father-son spy showdown?

Both sides of the Taiwan Strait truly seem cut from the same cloth—these crude political persecution tactics look so identical that it is hard to tell who is copying whom.

This time, the Tsai Ing-wen administration invoked the Classified National Security Information Protection Act (or perhaps the National Security Act, I forget which) to detain Wang Bing-zhong and his associates. Under the provisions of the Classified National Security Information Protection Act, once criminal proceedings for the “Wang Bing-zhong case” are initiated, the investigation can remain classified in complete secrecy throughout. Even when formal indictments are filed and the case enters the trial phase, it can still proceed behind closed doors.

In contrast, even Lee Ming-che’s trial on the mainland was not quite this covert (forced confessions notwithstanding). Who could have imagined that in Taiwan, which prides itself on democracy and the rule of law, stepping through the doors of the prosecutor’s office could mean vanishing into thin air!

In ancient times, General Yue Fei was recalled from the front lines by twelve golden plaques issued in rapid succession. Today, we have Bing-zhong being struck with three simultaneous legal summonses. The difference is that Yue Fei was fighting invaders until jealous courtiers intervened, whereas Wang Bing-zhong belongs to a minor opposition party, and is merely a minor figure within it. If someone of his stature can be accused of violating the National Security Act for treasonous collaboration with the enemy, I am truly at a loss for words.

Perhaps Wang Bing-zhong is the first person to be arrested for “pro-communist” associations since the lifting of martial law. Actually, scratch that—people soon learned that Hou Han-ting and two other young New Party members were similarly taken from their homes using the exact same playbook.

In reality, the Democratic Progressive Party’s (DPP) ultimate target remains the KMT. Moving against the New Party today—and targeting minor figures at that—might just be testing the waters. Beyond suppressing the momentum of these up-and-coming figures in the New Party, it gauges whether such crude political intimidation tactics can gain acceptance in Taiwanese society today.

What is deeply disheartening is that after reading comments from online netizens, I found that such political maneuvering might actually succeed. Writing this now leaves me with a lingering sense of unease, wondering if one day someone will come knocking to haul me in for questioning on fabricated charges.

Many online commentators grew bizarrely euphoric upon hearing that Wang Bing-zhong and Hou Han-ting had been taken in by the Investigation Bureau. Like manic crowds, they cheered across the internet, asserting that these people deserved it. Comments ranged from extreme outbursts such as: “Treason, execute him!”, “He should have been locked up long ago”, “Does this even need explaining? Do they think people in Taiwan are stupid? Oh wait… they are”, to “The investigators handled this poorly, letting it drag on this long.”

Well, just another ordinary day on PTT.

Still, I would like to ask these netizens: is the Republic of China (ROC) still a country governed by democracy and the rule of law?

Why not just shutter the courthouse doors altogether? Nowadays, as long as the government can obtain a search warrant, it suffices for mobs of netizens to stage a joyful public trial. As long as it wraps itself in the banner of “transitional justice,” due process can be casually discarded to exercise authoritarian power reminiscent of the Hitler era.

Wait a second, do netizens even understand the basics? First off, Wang’s legal status was merely that of a witness (at least according to the Investigation Bureau’s public statements), and secondly, no court has handed down any verdict. Yet legions of netizens are already treating Wang Bing-zhong as if he were on the ten most wanted list. Isn’t that absurd?

Of course, although the Investigation Bureau officially labeled him a “witness,” the procedure fully mirrored the posturing of the martial law era—dispatching a massive squad of black-clad personnel to make the pickup. That kind of “witness” treatment is downright terrifying.

Others argue there is a clear difference between Wang Bing-zhong being detained by the Investigation Bureau today and the Independent Taiwan Association incident where four youths were arbitrarily arrested by police as criminal suspects. But pray tell, what is the practical difference between a criminal suspect and a “witness” slapped with a search warrant and a pre-prepared arrest warrant?

To me, they look virtually indistinguishable.

According to Article 128 of the Code of Criminal Procedure: “A search warrant shall specify the following matters: the cause of the case; the defendant, criminal suspect, or object to be searched or seized…” In other words, issuing a search warrant inherently presumes that the target is a defendant or a criminal suspect.

It seems that shifting positions changes one’s mindset—not only for politicians, but for the onlookers in the peanut gallery as well. Even the presumption of innocence, which netizens love to champion, gets flushed down the toilet. People can vehemently oppose something in the past, yet vigorously applaud the exact same action once the political roles are reversed.

What an astounding feat of mental gymnastics!

Not to mention the sloppy, heavy-handed manner in which the Investigation Bureau handled the summons and detention. For example, two government agencies simultaneously demanded that the individual appear at two different locations at the exact same hour, threatening to execute an arrest warrant if he failed to comply. This looks uncomfortably close to an intentional attempt to trap someone into legal culpability.

By the way, how many people accidentally called Wang Bing-zhong “Wang Wei-zhong” today? Raise your hands and confess! (Blushing and raising hand)

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account