Regarding the incident where the National Communications Commission (NCC) of the Republic of China forcibly pulled private broadcaster channels off the air to reclaim frequencies in BCC Music Network ‘i Radio’ and Formosa Network Abruptly Forced Off the Air by NCC, the Broadcasting Corporation of China (BCC) filed an administrative lawsuit. The collegial panel of the Taipei High Administrative Court ruled that the NCC had abused its administrative discretion by imposing attached riders reserving revocation rights and stipulating that “no compensation may be claimed upon notification of frequency surrender.” Because these conditions infringed upon constitutionally guaranteed rights to litigation, the court revoked the riders and ordered the NCC to re-evaluate BCC’s license renewal application dated December 30, 2015, and render a fresh administrative decision. The case remains subject to appeal.
Legal experts observed that if BCC prevails definitively on appeal, given the government’s current stance, it is unlikely the two frequencies will be returned after reconsideration. Consequently, BCC will almost certainly seek financial remedy through state compensation lawsuits. The damages resulting from the NCC’s abuse of authority would effectively mean all taxpayers foot the bill for the government’s unlawful conduct. In response, the NCC stated that the regulatory disposition allocating frequencies to the Hakka Radio Station and the Indigenous Peoples Radio Station was finalized and unaffected by this verdict, operating strictly under the law without question. NCC Vice Chairman Wong Po-tsung even remarked that BCC had made commitments “voluntarily in black and white” at the time, confirming that the agency will certainly appeal upon receiving the written judgment.
On June 30 two years ago, the NCC approved the license renewals for BCC’s Music Network and Formosa Network, but attached a condition reserving revocation rights. It demanded that BCC cease broadcasting unconditionally and surrender the frequencies without seeking compensation whenever notified by the NCC.
Late that year, the NCC ordered BCC to stop using the frequencies of Formosa Network and Music Network starting March 1 of the following year, barring any request for compensation. BCC condemned the NCC’s actions as political persecution and, after its administrative appeal was dismissed, initiated judicial proceedings in administrative court.
The Taipei High Administrative Court noted that the policy to counter mainland propaganda broadcasts had officially terminated in 2004. BCC’s 2010 license renewal was approved unconditionally based on statutory requirements, completely divorced from historical propaganda containment policies. Although the NCC resolved on December 1 two years ago to compel BCC to cease broadcasts by March 1, the NCC did not even approve the allocation applications from the Hakka Affairs Council and the Indigenous Peoples Cultural Foundation until December 5.
The court’s collegial panel determined that while claiming compensation does not guarantee success, the NCC’s blanket revocation rider forcefully deprived BCC of its right to seek compensation, violating citizens’ constitutional right to legal recourse. If such riders were permitted, administrative agencies could attach waivers denying compensation or state reparations to every discretionary order, immunizing themselves from liability—an overreach that violates the rights guaranteed to citizens under the Constitution.
Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights
Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.
Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.
Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account


Comments