In 2011, Matsushita Health Living Workshop Co., Ltd. in Taoyuan County promoted its “Taihe Workshop Negative Ion Energy Health Bottle TR55,” claiming the plastic kettle and water bottle line was completely free of plasticizers and could withstand high temperatures up to 135°C. However, testing conducted by the Hualien County Public Health Bureau revealed that the bottle leached plasticizers once liquid temperatures reached 80°C. Accusing the company of deceptive advertising, the bureau formally requested the Taoyuan County Government to take enforcement action under relevant consumer protection laws.

Taoyuan County Health Bureau Director Liu Yi-lien stated that upon receiving official documentation from the Hualien County Public Health Bureau, inspectors would immediately be dispatched to examine the claims, and regulatory penalties would be imposed if false advertising or misleading labeling was confirmed.

Matsushita Health Living Workshop responded that the raw resin used in the bottle was imported from Switzerland and that the company had submitted samples to SGS Taiwan for inspection, where nine major plasticizers returned “Not Detected” ratings. Representatives sent to the Hualien County Public Health Bureau were told that while “Not Detected” complied with regulatory thresholds, products cannot legally be advertised with definitive claims like “Contains No Plasticizer” or “100% Free.” The company pledged to exercise greater caution in its future promotional copy.

Huang Yuan-gui, the regional distributor for Hualien and Taitung, noted that the health bottle enjoyed strong sales in countries such as Japan, and maintained that health officials merely took issue with the advertising slogan “Contains No Plasticizers.” He indicated he would coordinate with the master distributor to remove the offending phrases, though the product would not be pulled from store shelves.

Intrigued by the distributor’s claim that “the bottle enjoyed strong sales in countries such as Japan,” we conducted a search across Japanese e-commerce channels (including Amazon Japan and eBay), but found no listings for Taihe Workshop products.

“I want a refund!” exclaimed Ms. Lin, a Hualien resident who bought two TR55 bottles during a Father’s Day promotion for her children. “The company advertised heavily and claimed to use imported Swiss materials. I assumed it would be completely safe, but it turned out to be exaggerated and deceptive advertising.”

Hualien County Health Bureau Director Hsu Hsiang-ming explained that earlier this month he noticed advertisements claiming the bottles contained no plasticizers. Believing that for plastic goods, plasticizer content is generally a matter of degrees, he purchased units for laboratory analysis. Although the results did not breach the national safety limits of the Republic of China, a leaching concentration of 0.14 ppm was detected at 80°C, confirming that marketing claims of “completely free” misled consumers.

Mr. Liu, a worker in Hualien whose girlfriend had gifted him the same bottle nearly a year ago, expressed deep concern after using it daily for hot tea, worried about how much plasticizer he might have unknowingly consumed.

Taihe Workshop operates retail chain locations across Taiwan Province. The brand promoted its bottles as high-temperature safe, suitable for brewing hot tea, and infused with negative ions that purportedly improve water taste. Priced around NT$900 each, the bottles command a substantial premium over conventional drinkware.

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account