Around 7:00 PM, the antique glass door of a used bookstore was pushed open slowly. Accompanied by the chime of the bell, a boy walked in wearing a modest plaid suit and a felt flat cap.

After closing the door, the boy nodded to the old man sitting behind the counter by the entrance, then walked briskly and familiarly straight toward the depths of the bookstore. The old man behind the counter wore a faint, indifferent expression, merely watching the boy through his shiny silver-rimmed glasses until he disappeared into the dim corridors of stacked bookshelves.

At 8:00 PM, the bookstore’s door was pushed open forcefully once again, and a group of young high school students dressed in navy blue suits walked in. Boisterous and noisy, they looked around the secondhand bookstore, browsing everywhere for interesting books. After a while, one student chuckled to a companion: “This bookstore is really rundown. There isn’t even a decent book, the floor creaks, no wonder there’s not a single customer.”

Hearing this, the old man stared in terror toward the back of the shop, muttering under his breath: “Where is the boy!?”

The above is the scenario for my latest “Turtle Soup” (also known as lateral thinking puzzle or situation puzzle) creation: “The Boy Who Disappeared in the Second-Hand Bookshop.”

In this game, the hidden truth of the story is deduced through questions asked by the players, while the story creator can only answer “YES” or “NO” to each inquiry.

Below, besides revealing the truth behind the story, I’ve also recorded several questions asked by friends on Facebook. Anyone interested is welcome to take this puzzle and challenge your friends! ;-)

The difficulty of this story is quite easy (truth be told, I settled on the bookstore setting first and struggled to come up with something eerie).

Q&A Log

  1. Q: Was the bookstore the boy’s home? A: NO.
  2. Q: Did the boy run into the bookstore to escape bullying from high schoolers? A: NO.
  3. Q: Did the boy slip out through the back door? A: NO.
  4. Q: Is the boy still inside the bookstore? A: YES.
  5. Q: Did the boy open a horror novel and get sucked into the story? A: NO, this isn’t fantasy fiction.
  6. Q: Was the boy taking a nap in the back of the bookstore? A: NO.

The Truth of the Story

This second-hand bookstore was a vintage shop with quite a long history, appearing rather out of place in the modern city center. Most fixtures inside were aged and weathered, needing frequent maintenance and care to withstand the relentless march of time.

Unfortunately, during this dreary, rainy winter, the wooden floorboards in the back of the bookstore could no longer bear the weight of numerous heavy bookshelves, cracking open into a large gaping hole.

The boy in the story habitually dropped by the bookstore after dinner, casually browsing interesting novels to enjoy the fleeting moments of tranquility unique to old bookshops.

However, because of the light drizzle outside before leaving today, the boy put on a cap that slightly obstructed his vision. Coupled with the bookstore’s dim lighting, the boy failed to notice that the floorboards along the aisle had become as fragile as paper. As he walked past, he fell headlong through the hole into the basement. Knocked unconscious by the heavy impact, he lay motionless below.

That is why the high schoolers never noticed another customer was in the bookstore.

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account