The Fair Trade Commission (FTC) of the Republic of China recently sent shockwaves through the tech sector by slapping Qualcomm with a staggering NT$23.4 billion antitrust penalty. Following mainland China, South Korea, and the European Union, the Republic of China became the fourth jurisdiction to impose major government fines against Qualcomm. Nevertheless, industry insiders and business leaders have voiced astonishment and pointed criticism over the FTC’s aggressive enforcement.

In response, the Ministry of Economic Affairs (MOEA) issued a press release on October 17 expressing “deep concern” over the FTC’s NT$23.4 billion penalty. Qualcomm placed orders totaling NT$155.7 billion with Taiwan-based suppliers last year and was expected to drive NT$432.4 billion in network and communications output value this year. The MOEA cautioned that the ruling failed to consider Qualcomm’s contribution to the broader industrial ecosystem and future collaboration opportunities, which could adversely affect foreign direct investment in Taiwan.

Addressing the differing stances between the two executive agencies, senior officials at the Executive Yuan stated that the FTC is an independent regulatory body whose decisions must be respected. Furthermore, the FTC’s formal written determination has not yet been delivered, and dissenting opinions were recorded among certain commissioners, which could potentially serve as grounds for Qualcomm if it pursues an administrative lawsuit.

Qualcomm was heavily penalized by the FTC last week. Amid rumors that Qualcomm CEO Steve Mollenkopf might visit Taiwan to attend TSMC’s 30th anniversary celebrations, the MOEA’s proactive press statement setting out its position drew intense public attention.

Economics Minister Shen Jong-chin initially stated that he “respected the FTC,” but six days later, the ministry took an assertive turn, issuing a statement expressing “deep concern” over the decision.

Senior MOEA officials pointed out that Article 1 of the Fair Trade Act specifies that the law was enacted to maintain trading order, protect consumer interests, ensure free and fair competition, and “promote economic stability and prosperity.” Because this case carries substantial ramifications for industrial development in Taiwan, the ministry felt compelled to make its position clear.

The MOEA stated that, as the primary authority overseeing industrial growth, it hopes industrial competitiveness and fair trade can be reconciled while keeping economic stability and prosperity in mind. Given the investigation and adjudication process, the announcement made in the FTC press release, and the massive NT$23.4 billion fine, the MOEA remains deeply apprehensive.

According to the ministry, Qualcomm has long been an indispensable partner for Taiwan’s ICT and semiconductor sectors. Its business footprint spans the entire mobile communications ecosystem, encompassing smartphones, tablets, laptops, IoT infrastructure, network carriers, and testing services.

According to data from the Market Intelligence & Consulting Institute (MIC) under the Institute for Information Industry, Qualcomm placed approximately NT$155.7 billion in purchase orders with Taiwan’s semiconductor, packaging, and testing industries in 2016, catalyzing an estimated NT$314.7 billion in networking and telecommunications output value, projected to reach NT$432.4 billion in 2017. Looking ahead, partnerships are set to expand into 5G, artificial intelligence, automotive electronics, healthcare, and smart manufacturing.

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account