I came across a brain-teaser/IQ test puzzle on Facebook. A friend tried solving it using independent variables, dependent variables, and constants, eventually arriving at a unique single solution. Then he mentioned finding the original author’s answer online, which claimed there could actually be two valid answers. In my opinion, both of them are partly right and partly wrong.
Below is this so-called high-IQ puzzle along with my own answer and perspective for your reference. It is said that anyone who can solve it within five minutes has an IQ over 130!
The Puzzle:
“If yesterday was tomorrow, today would be Friday.”
Question: Which day of the week is “today” in this sentence?
- Wednesday
- Thursday
- Friday
- Sunday
.
(Try solving it yourself first!)
.
My Personal Solution:
Because natural language phrasing possesses its own logic, looking purely at the sentence structure, we can interpret the problem as:
“If yesterday (Saturday) was tomorrow, then today would be Friday.”
Therefore, the actual real date today is Sunday.
However, setting aside linguistic nuances and thinking purely from mathematical logic and symbolic reasoning, both “yesterday” and “tomorrow” can serve as the truth anchor (True). This produces two statements: “Yesterday (True) is tomorrow” versus “Yesterday is tomorrow (True).” Only when these two states are evaluated independently does the situation arise where both Wednesday and Sunday can be valid answers, as the original author noted. In other words, although the author designed a math problem wrapped in words, they were thinking purely about the math (undoubtedly a math major).
From this perspective, we can look at the original statement through the other lens:
“If yesterday ← tomorrow (Thursday is true), then today would be Friday.”
Therefore, another actual real date today is Wednesday.
I intentionally used the ”←” symbol here because one cannot violate the directional flow of the phrasing, which is precisely the conceptual bottleneck that causes a mental block. The more you obsess over what “is” represents, the more maddening it gets.
Postscript:
My algebra is honestly not great, so looking at algebraic XY equations makes my head spin a bit (though I always scored 100 on geometry). Whenever I see these kinds of brain-teasers or IQ quizzes, I feel that how good one was at math during school days was heavily influenced by one’s language comprehension. (Ironically, teachers who excel at literature are usually terrible at math.)
This problem is a classic case heavily dependent on verbal formulation. The creator wanted to use words to frame a mathematical problem, forgetting that natural language logic is far more slippery than pure mathematics (because it easily invites divergent interpretations). My Facebook friend is very knowledgeable, yet he fell into the STEM mindset trap—relying solely on mathematical formulas while overlooking the inherent logic of linguistic syntax. By rigidly plugging in algebraic variables, he remained convinced there was only one solution and assumed the author was confused.
That’s why I always say creators of these riddles just love making trouble out of nothing, slapping big banners like “High IQ Test” or “Google Interview Question” onto them to lure countless curious minds into heated debates.
Reader Q&A
The Classic Logic Debate: Is Today “Wednesday” or “Sunday”? (Readers Chien-Hsiung Huang, Azrael, Elson)
In-Depth Reader Perspectives:
- Chien-Hsiung Huang’s view: Believing today is Wednesday feels unnatural syntactically; it only works mathematically when treating yesterday and tomorrow as interchangeable peers. When a subject takes a tense verb, there is grammatical hierarchy. The meaning is set by “if yesterday,” making Wednesday syntactically invalid. Sunday is the only real answer.
- Azrael’s view: There is only one answer: Sunday! “Yesterday” refers to an established fact (yesterday was Saturday, today is Sunday). Assuming Saturday becomes tomorrow, today would be Friday, perfectly matching the psychological longing for the weekend.
- Elson’s view: If yesterday was Thursday, today would be Friday; meaning tomorrow = Thursday, hence today = Wednesday.
Vedfolnir Dimensional Analysis:
The reason this long-debated internet riddle causes science and humanities minds to clash so fiercely lies right at the intersection of linguistic perspective and mathematical coordinate systems!
The riddle originally stems from the classic English logic puzzle:
"If yesterday was tomorrow, today would be Friday."
The reason two opposing camps—“Sunday” versus “Wednesday”—emerge is essentially because solvers choose different “reference frames” along the timeline:
-
Shift forward relative to “real yesterday” (yielding Sunday):
- Imagined today: Friday $\rightarrow$ Imagined tomorrow: Saturday.
- Statement says “If yesterday was tomorrow (Saturday)” $\rightarrow$ Real yesterday = Saturday.
- Since real yesterday was Saturday, real today is “Sunday”.
- (This aligns with Azrael’s intuition, prioritizing chronological event sequencing.)
-
Shift backward relative to “imagined tomorrow” (yielding Wednesday):
- Imagined today: Friday $\rightarrow$ Imagined yesterday: Thursday.
- Statement says “If yesterday (Thursday) was tomorrow” $\rightarrow$ Real tomorrow = Thursday.
- Since real tomorrow is Thursday, real today is “Wednesday”.
- (This aligns with Elson’s symmetric relative displacement equation in pure algebra.)
Regarding Mr. Huang’s point about tense and verbal hierarchy, it highlights the structural difference between Chinese and English: Chinese is an isolating language lacking morphological inflection; its copula “是” does not convey subjunctive mood or tense shifts the way English does. Trying to scrutinize tense hierarchy using translated Chinese sentences essentially forces an Indo-European grammatical model onto Chinese characters, creating an illusion of syntactic rupture.
Stepping beyond a single perspective to see the structural symmetry and linguistic boundaries supporting both answers is where the true beauty of this puzzle lies!
Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights
Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.
Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.
Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account



Comments