During a half-day interview in Japan with a living national treasure master, he cheerfully pointed out a photo of himself with Tsai Ing-wen assisting her election campaign. In our conversation, he shared that throughout his lifelong dedication to refining calligraphy, his absolute favorite museum to visit was the National Palace Museum of our Republic of China. Even though he generally disliked traveling, the sole reason he flew to Taiwan every single year was to make a pilgrimage to the Palace Museum and study calligraphy relics created by historic masters.

Yet hearing these past two days that the National Palace Museum is preparing to shut down completely for a whopping three years makes one wonder if the government has been run over by a train.

Fortunately, Legislator Ko Chih-en blew the whistle to alert the public: an internal Palace Museum meeting decided that the Northern Branch would close for three years starting the year after next, during which exhibits would be shifted south to the Southern Branch. Palace Museum Director Chen Chi-nan confirmed that they were “evaluating the necessity of such a plan.”

Relocating countless fragile cultural relics and priceless masterpieces from the National Palace Museum demands an enormous expenditure of manpower and resources. Moreover, many ancient artifacts are inherently fragile and unfit for long-distance transport.

Barring a catastrophic fire or foreign military invasion, world-class international museums across the globe manage renovations and expansions via phased, zoned construction while balancing visitor operations. To date, we have never seen any national-level museum arrogantly tell its citizens that it is abruptly shutting down for three years.

A friend originally proposed a few conspiracy theories: perhaps it was intended to artificially boost crowds at the Southern Branch, or maybe to cripple Taipei’s tourism numbers two years down the road so Ko Wen-je would face political fallout if he ran for president. Incredibly, my friend’s dark predictions hit uncomfortably close to home. Before long, news broke showing the museum director himself openly speaking about funneling traffic to the Southern Branch, followed by reports of politicians meddling behind closed doors. With suspicious motives swirling, how can citizens be expected to trust this administration?

While I have total faith in the professional curatorial and preservation staff at the Palace Museum, undertaking massive relocation inherently spikes the probability of catastrophic accidents.

What possible reason justifies gambling with national treasures just to shut the entire complex down for three years?

Don’t tell me about insurance; I would rather these priceless treasures remain intact and undamaged.

Even more absurdly, the actual structural renovation work on the main Palace Museum complex only takes one year. The remaining two years are allegedly just for packaging and transporting the relics.

Seriously?????

A Facebook friend argued that everyone was over-politicizing the matter, claiming she looked forward to the museum expanding after three years of closure into a mega-venue like the British Museum that takes days to explore.

Well, hate to break it to you, but that is nothing more than an unrealistic daydream.

Another acquaintance asked whether the south didn’t deserve a branch museum, or whether southerners didn’t deserve to appreciate art.

That is yet another overly emotional and unhelpful reaction. Tainan’s Chimei Museum is managed brilliantly, isn’t it?

Does the British Museum feel compelled to scatter duplicate branches across every corner of the United Kingdom?

What we should really examine is how preposterous it was when a former president stubbornly insisted on building a remote branch in the south in the first place. After constructing an inconvenient southern outpost (who knows if old political tricks like land speculation around the site were involved?), they insisted on rebranding the historic Taipei main museum as the “Northern Branch.” And now they want to haul the irreplaceable treasures down south. Such everyday political gaslighting and flawed logic are on full display.

Let’s conclude with a bit of biting satire:

“What do you do when you build a knockoff white-elephant museum that lacks exhibits?”

“Just shut down the National Palace Museum, of course.”

“To exhibit dengue mosquitoes instead?” chimed in a friend even more cynical than I am.

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account