In numerous high-profile social news stories and political-economic judicial cases, a familiar scene plays out repeatedly: suspects or persons involved in an investigation hold a press conference after being released on bail or released from custody, publicly accusing prosecutors and police officers of sternly warning them—often in intimidating tones during interrogation—not to discuss case facts or substantive questioning details with the outside world.

During those interrogations, investigating authorities solemnly invoke a resonant legal term: “Confidentiality of Investigation”.

Even more absurdly, in certain public safety incidents or emergencies, some suspects adopt the same rhetoric, brazenly wielding “confidentiality of investigation” as a convenient shield to refuse answering questions or evade cooperating with authorities to eliminate on-site safety hazards.

Observing these bizarre phenomena in legal practice and media reporting compels a serious question: how did public discourse in Taiwan develop such a profound cognitive distortion and misuse regarding the principle of “confidentiality of investigation”?


What Is “Confidentiality of Investigation”? What Is Its Real Legislative Purpose?

To clarify who is bound by this principle, we must first return to the jurisprudential foundations of modern rule of law: why does a legal system require investigations to remain confidential?

In criminal procedure, the core legislative intent behind the confidentiality of investigations revolves around four sacred objectives:

  1. Ensuring Smooth Investigation Proceedings: Preventing co-conspirators from colluding, destroying evidence, fabricating testimony, or fleeing the country, thereby guaranteeing that judicial power can effectively prosecute crimes.
  2. Promoting the Discovery of Objective Truth: Preventing premature leaks of fragmented, unverified investigative scraps that could contaminate witness testimonies.
  3. Upholding the Presumption of Innocence and Protecting Reputation: Anyone accused of a crime is presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law by final judgment. Allegations at the investigation stage are preliminary; prematurely disclosing a suspect’s identity and private affairs can permanently ruin their social reputation even if they are later fully exonerated.
  4. Preventing Public Prejudgment and Safeguarding Independent Adjudication: Preventing investigating agencies from manipulating public opinion via media leaks or conducting “trial by media,” which exerts external pressure on the judge’s independent deliberation.

As shown clearly by these four points: the protective umbrella of investigation confidentiality was primarily designed to protect defendants and criminal suspects!


Examining the Statutory Text: Who Exactly Does Article 245 of the Code of Criminal Procedure Regulate?

Let us examine the explicit provisions of Article 245 of the Republic of China’s Code of Criminal Procedure:

Code of Criminal Procedure, Article 245:

Investigations shall not be made public.

The defense attorney of a defendant or a criminal suspect may be present when a prosecutor, a prosecutor investigator, a judicial police officer, or a judicial police interrogates the defendant or suspect, and may state opinions…

Prosecutors, prosecutor investigators, judicial police officers, judicial police, defense attorneys, agents ad litem of complainants, and other persons performing official duties in the investigation proceedings in accordance with the law shall not disclose or reveal matters known to them in the performance of their duties during the investigation to persons outside the scope necessary for the performance of their statutory duties, unless otherwise provided by laws or regulations, or where necessary for maintaining the public interest or protecting lawful rights and interests.

Examine the regulated subjects explicitly enumerated in the third paragraph:

  • Prosecutors and prosecutor investigators;
  • Judicial police officers and judicial police;
  • Defense attorneys and agents ad litem of complainants;
  • And other “persons performing official duties in the investigation proceedings in accordance with the law”.

The statutory language is clear in black and white: the only subjects bound by the principle of confidentiality of investigation are law enforcement officers of state power, judicial civil servants, and designated legal representatives participating in investigation proceedings under the law!

The essence of this provision is the concrete application in criminal procedure of the criminal offense of “Civil Servant Divulging Secrets Other Than National Defense Secrets.” Its purpose is to constrain state civil servants wielding investigative power, strictly forbidding them from leaking documents, tipping off select media outlets, or manipulating public opinion to smear reputations.

As for the “defendant,” “criminal suspect,” “victim,” or “general witnesses” involved in the case, they are not within the scope of regulated or penalized entities under this statute at all!


Is It a Crime for Defendants and Suspects to Speak to the Public?

When an individual is prosecuted by state public authority, they enjoy fundamental constitutional and statutory protections, including the privilege against self-incrimination and procedural defense rights.

Inside the courtroom, defendants not only have the right to remain silent, but due to their unique defense status, even if they make untrue statements during interrogation, as long as it does not involve malicious false accusation against others, they are not subject to penalties for perjury (which applies only to witnesses under oath).

If courtroom statements are shielded by such high constitutional protection, what about after stepping outside the interrogation room?

If a defendant or suspect steps out of the district prosecutors office, feels unfairly treated by the judicial process, and holds a press conference to publicly declare their innocence, clarify their stance to the public, or criticize the arrogant demeanor or preconceptions of the interrogator—this constitutes a legitimate exercise of constitutionally protected freedom of speech and litigation defense rights. How could that be illegal? What penal provision could it possibly violate?

Furthermore, information learned by a defendant during interrogation could only fall under special statutory penalties or invasion of privacy laws in extraordinary exceptions (such as leaking genuine state defense secrets obtained during case-file reviews, or intentionally disseminating extreme personal privacy unrelated to the case). General statements regarding one’s own case and interrogation experience are completely unbound by the principle of confidentiality of investigation.


Widespread and persistent misunderstandings of this legal provision have produced two absurd phenomena in the judicial environment in Taiwan:

1. Law Enforcement Using “Investigation Confidentiality” as a Gag Order

Some investigating officers habitually exert psychological pressure on suspects after questioning, threatening them with warnings like: “If you dare speak to anyone outside, you will be violating investigation confidentiality and leaking secrets!” This is not only a grave distortion of the law, but an abusive overreach of public authority suppressing citizens’ defense rights. What law enforcement officers need to constrain is their own communication channels and PR behavior, not intimidate citizens into silence.

2. Suspects Wielding “Investigation Confidentiality” as an Evasive Shield

Another absurdity occurs when suspects or controversial figures, facing public safety inquiries or official administrative inspections, solemnly claim: “Because investigations are confidential, I cannot answer,” or “I am withholding data to comply with investigation confidentiality.”

While suspects in criminal proceedings indeed hold a statutory right to remain silent, you may say “I exercise my right to remain silent,” rather than distorting concepts and pretending to be a law-abiding public servant bound by Article 245 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.


Conclusion

Statutory language requires rigorous reading, and the spirit of the rule of law demands honest defense.

“Confidentiality of investigation” is a bridle placed upon the head of state machinery and law enforcement officers. It exists to restrain power, prevent abuse, and safeguard individual reputations and judicial fairness.

If one day this safeguard—originally designed to protect suspects—is inverted by law enforcement to serve as a club to silence citizens, or used by controversial parties as a veil to escape public scrutiny, it is not only a bitter irony to the modern rule of law, but an alarming warning sign of collective decline in civic legal literacy.

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account