Last night was anything but peaceful. Right after stepping out of the shower, a family member suffered a sudden wave of dizziness and collapsed onto the floor. We dialled 119 immediately, and an ambulance rushed us to the emergency room at Mackay Memorial Hospital.

While waiting for biochemical test results and medical checkups, old habits died hard: whenever an opportunity presented itself, I couldn’t resist lobbing endless seemingly foolish questions. This provoked repeated eye-rolls from the pretty nurse attending our bed. Well, her eye-rolls were genuinely cute nonetheless (cue flying kicks).

Back in my naïve teenage days, I had already learned from ample experience that if you want to admire someone rolling their eyes, just keep asking questions.

Waiting by the bed, I watched the handful of ER doctors darting between beds and crowds like busy bees. The nocturnal human tide in the emergency room created a peculiar night-owl spectacle, rivalling Zhongshan North Road and Golden Jaguar.

Taking advantage of the lull before lab results came back, I chatted with an elderly volunteer assistant. She told me that tonight was actually considered a relatively calm shift—making it hard to fathom how hectic and chaotic a truly overwhelmed ER can get.

Perhaps part of me half-expected some unruly troublemaker to harass the pretty nurse, giving me the chance to play out a late-night hero-saves-the-beauty sequence (cue flying kicks from the entire nursing staff).

How frantically busy an emergency room becomes during major disasters is something you can somewhat grasp from disaster films, but experiencing it firsthand is an entirely different matter.

Among all the provocative questions I asked in the Mackay Memorial Hospital ER last night, the most classic one occurred when we were finally preparing to leave, and the physician handed us the billing slip and prescription:

“Doctor, out of these four prescribed medications, do you genuinely believe they offer positive therapeutic value or symptomatic relief for the condition, or are they written simply to help the hospital claim NHI reimbursement?” (Inner voice: This guy is truly the world’s biggest nuisance.)

Having dabbled in biomedical engineering during my student days, I actually don’t mind prescriptions written purely for revenue. After all, hospitals require operating income to sustain physician training, research, and development.

Yet ordinary citizens should at least retain the autonomy to choose whether to take redundant drugs—preventing the collective complacency that accelerates the financial black hole of drug pricing. Especially when a physician cannot pinpoint the exact root cause of an illness (don’t be surprised; the human body is extraordinarily intricate) yet still hands over a bundle of prescriptions, the odds that I choose not to take them rise dramatically.

To put it simply: you can prescribe the medication, but unless truly necessary, I don’t necessarily have to ingest it. While I place (conditional) trust in physicians and even greater trust in empirical data, an intriguing and peculiar divide exists between hospital bureaucracy and everyday patients.

Necessity is the fundamental premise. I can accept doctors writing routine prescriptions, but they should at least be candid about whether taking them is strictly indispensable.

Far too many unnecessary medications are churned out of institutional and bureaucratic maneuvering, ultimately feeding into the costliest NHI deficit in history.

When I caught a severe cold as a child, my parents dragged me to a local clinic. Following routine consultation and auscultation, the doctor swiftly tapped various bewildering pharmaceutical names into the computer.

Since no other patients were waiting in line, my old inquisitiveness flared up again, and I started bantering with the doctor with endless questions.

As we chatted, the veteran physician surprisingly remarked that the best treatment was simply drinking lots of water and getting plenty of rest, advising me to avoid taking the pills if possible.

Huh? His honesty triggered a flurry of silent expletives: then why on earth did you prescribe a mountain of pills in the first place?

As I grew older and gained more medical awareness, I learned that many medications are not meant to “cure,” but merely to suppress discomfort, leaving actual recovery to the body’s innate self-healing capabilities.

Though symptomatic rather than curative, they aren’t mere placebos. If temporary relief allows the body to rest comfortably, baseline resistance and regenerative power should theoretically function better (though conversely, suppressing certain symptoms can sometimes deceive the immune system and retard genuine recovery).

Finally, a closing observation: many critics fiercely attack the National Health Insurance policy for partisan motives or various grievances. However, on the whole, the Republic of China’s National Health Insurance system (NHI) remains a world-class institutional achievement that our citizens can be genuinely proud of. Alongside universal basic income, it stands as a visionary, epoch-making framework.

Executing a policy of such depth and breadth naturally comes with immense operational challenges, and complaints frequently dominate news headlines. Yet constructive, actionable proposals for improvement are seldom heard—often, the loudest complainers are themselves contributors to the systemic deficit. Criticising only demands a narrow vantage point, and there is never a shortage of critics.

A truly brilliant and creative solution, however, is a once-in-a-century treasure. Therefore, rather than exhausting energy on cheap criticism, refining our thoughts with greater nuance and care might just yield an exceptional breakthrough.

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account