One day, a young man visits a shoe shop to purchase shoes. The cost of the shoes to the shop is $15, and the retail price is $21. The young man hands over a $50 bill. Lacking small change, the shopkeeper takes the young man’s $50 bill to a neighboring shop to exchange it for fifty $1 bills, then gives the young man the pair of shoes plus $29 in change. Shortly afterward, the neighbor discovers that the $50 bill is counterfeit, forcing the shoe shop owner to repay the neighbor $50 in real money. How much money did the shoe store lose in total throughout this transaction?

Previously, when the news reported on this riddle, they consulted a math teacher who arrived at the answer of $94. The teacher’s logic: adding the $15 cost of shoes, plus the $29 given to the young man, plus the $50 repaid to the neighbor, totaling a $94 loss.

Many online commentators suggested an answer of $44: calculated simply as the $29 change given to the young man plus the $15 cost price of the shoes.

Our earlier calculation came out to $79 (or $73), breaking down the process as follows:

  1. The young man gained $29 in cash plus a pair of shoes valued at $21.
  2. The neighbor suffered only a negligible time loss.
  3. The shoe store gave the young man $29 cash, a pair of shoes costing $15, and lost expected net profit of $6, totaling $50 in expected value.
  4. From the $50 exchanged with the neighbor, $29 went to the buyer. The shopkeeper had to make up the missing amount out of pocket to return $50 to the neighbor. Covering the $29 deficit plus the initial $50 loss meant an apparent total loss of $79.
  5. If evaluated purely under historical accounting cost (ignoring the unrealized $6 profit margin), the present book value loss would be $73.

The primary difference in this argument was treating the cash swap with the neighbor as a zero-value transaction against $50. If the shoe store originally possessed enough change without involving the neighbor, the young man would gain $29 cash plus shoes worth $21, and the store would lose $29 cash plus the shoes at cost $15 (or value $21), matching the $44 (or $50) figure.

Had the neighbor never detected the counterfeit note, the neighbor would have lost $50, the customer would have gained $29 and shoes, while the store made its expected $6 profit.

However, exchanging money with the neighbor represented a distinct supplementary transaction. When the counterfeit was discovered, the shopkeeper had to return $50, but because part of the cash had already been handed out ($29 to the buyer), personal funds had to cover it, leading to a calculated loss of $79 (or $73).

Update on 2017.02.02: Looking back at this article years later, I honestly can’t fathom my original convoluted logic (laughs). Look at it simply from the shopkeeper’s net cash flow: you must pay the neighbor $50, you gave the buyer $29 cash plus a pair of shoes costing $15, and all you were left holding was a worthless fake piece of paper. The straightforward, correct answer is simply $44 in out-of-pocket loss ($29 cash + $15 shoes), or $94 if counting the total cash transfers plus shoe cost without offsetting the initial change received.

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account