Declaring oneself to be “number one” may be SpongeBob SquarePants’ favorite catchphrase, but in Taiwan, Republic of China (ROC), advertising yourself as the top-ranked website on search engines without verified substantiation resulted in a stiff regulatory fine. The Fair Trade Commission found the claim in violation of the Fair Trade Act and levied a penalty of NT$200,000.

According to a ruling passed during the 1,434th Commissioners’ Meeting of the Fair Trade Commission on May 1, 2019 (108th year of the ROC), Global Chinese Art Network Co., Ltd. published promotional copy in its 2016 Taiwan Emerging Artists Special Issue asserting that it was: “Awarded #1 in web search for ‘Art’ across Taiwan’s two major search engines, Yahoo and Google.”

ARTLIB Untrue Advertising

Screenshot of the deceptive promotional material published by Global Chinese Art Network Co., Ltd.

The Fair Trade Commission ruled that making misleading representations regarding service attributes that materially influence consumer transactional decisions violated Article 21, Paragraph 4, mutatis mutandis Paragraph 1, of the Fair Trade Act, penalizing the publisher NT$200,000.

Fair Trade Act, Chapter 3 (Unfair Competition), Article 21, Paragraph 1: “No enterprise shall make or use false or misleading representations or symbols in respect of price, quantity, quality, content, production process, date of manufacture, validity period, method of use, purpose of use, place of origin, manufacturer, place of manufacture, processor, or place of processing on goods or in advertisements, or by other means made known to the public.”

The Commission stated that the advertisement boldly declared the company ranked “#1 in searches for ‘Art’ across Yahoo and Google” without clearly disclosing the relevant historical timeframe. This ambiguity led the public to believe that during the publication period (2016) and subsequent digital distributions (2017–2018), querying the keyword “Art” on Yahoo and Google would yield the company’s portal as the top organic result. In reality, the firm could only produce ranking records dating back to 2012–2013; subsequent litigation involving site members had led to partial service shutdowns, precipitating a steep decline in traffic and ranking positions.

The Commission emphasized that relying on historical 2012–2013 data to market publications distributed in 2016 through 2018 misled consumers regarding current search dominance and distorted fair market competition, resulting in regulatory sanctions.

This landmark case serves as an educational benchmark for marketing and advertising practices across the corporate sector in the Republic of China (ROC), underscoring that exaggerated promotional slogans can compromise brand reputation and incur legal liabilities.

While the company had genuinely secured top positioning for certain art keywords in years past, search algorithms on Google and Bing fluctuate constantly. A transient top ranking years prior does not entitle a business to claim perpetual supremacy.

Similar marketing exaggerations are unfortunately prevalent across consumer goods—such as heaters falsely labeled as “German-engineered” or kettles branded to mimic Japanese origins using translated trademarks. We hope this enforcement precedent encourages greater authenticity and transparency in commercial advertising.

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account