A recent news report headlined “Graduate Student Proxy Ticket Service Deemed Ticket Scalping” noted that an incubation project called “Sit Back & Collect THSR Tickets,” developed by a student team at National Sun Yat-sen University, was suspected of violating the Railway Act. One of the project leaders, a graduate student surnamed Chang, defended the service: “We consulted the university’s legal counsel in advance; we are providing a genuine service with reasonable service fees, which does not violate the law.”

Student Chang added: “Currently, student discount tickets for Taiwan High Speed Rail can only be collected in person at station ticket counters, which is why we accepted these requests. We only book and retrieve tickets upon prior request from clients, which fundamentally differs from scalpers hoarding massive blocks of tickets in advance for resale.”

For context, another news story titled “THSR Scalper: Making NT$25 Profit Per Ticket” described an individual—coincidentally also surnamed Chang—who purchased periodic multi-ride passes and resold them, earning a profit of NT$25 per trip. Police determined this conduct breached Article 65 of the Railway Act, subjecting the seller to fines ranging from 1 to 10 times the original ticket price per ticket involved.

Article 65 of the Railway Act (Penalties): Any person who purchases railway tickets to resell them at a price higher than the face value, or to obtain illegal benefits for profit, shall be fined between one and ten times the face value of each ticket. The same penalty applies to those reselling booking vouchers or pickup vouchers at a higher price for profit. Anyone who uses fraudulent data or unlawful commands into computer systems or associated equipment to purchase tickets or acquire booking/pickup vouchers shall be fined between NT$50,000 and NT$500,000.

From a strict statutory standpoint, neither of the two individuals marked up the face value of the tickets, seemingly bypassing the first prong of Article 65. Whether their fees constitute “obtaining illegal benefits for profit,” however, remains open to legal interpretation.

The Sun Yat-sen University student team charged a service fee of NT$30 to NT$50 per student ticket booked. Under the THSR “College Student Discount Program,” which offers discounts up to 50% off, a one-way trip from Taipei to Zuoying costs NT$815, while the shortest trip to Banqiao is NT$20. Across the seven original stations, the average ticket price was roughly NT$397. If we assume an average handling fee of NT$40, the team’s fee accounted for about 10% of the discounted ticket value. Is a 10% markup substantial or modest?

Looking at it from the railway’s perspective, student discounts are a concessionary benefit provided to support students. For THSR, which has faced severe operational and financial pressures, student fares yield lower profit margins. When student ticket demand surges, it can crowd out full-fare passenger seats. If this proxy purchasing service significantly inflated student ticket booking rates, it is hardly surprising that THSR scrutinized their business model.

Furthermore, paragraph 2 of Article 65 of the Railway Act penalizes “entering fraudulent data or unlawful commands into computer systems,” which raises another pertinent issue.

Student Chang maintained that their team merely provided proxy booking and pickup services, collecting student details such as name, date of birth, university name, student ID number, and academic department upon registration. Yet THSR regulations explicitly state: “When purchasing tickets, passengers must present a valid student ID card at station ticket windows; each valid card may purchase only one ticket per trip.” How was the team able to batch-purchase so many student tickets at once? That must have been their operational secret (sips tea… knowing THSR tickets were not technically bound to student ID numbers on the magnetic stripe).

In this controversy, is THSR simply being inflexible by failing to distinguish between abusive hoarding and on-demand proxy purchasing, or did the graduate student team (and their consulted legal advisors) genuinely step over legal boundaries?

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account