Recently, I noticed that beyond hiring celebrities or traditional bloggers to endorse products, brands have started tapping personal Facebook users with large friend lists to share promotional experiences.
Honestly, this reflects some truly baffling marketing logic!
Celebrities possess established social capital; anything they utter captures immediate public and media attention. Sometimes merely lending their name to an inquiring agency for a newspaper mention generates substantial publicity. Even when celebrities barely understand what they are endorsing, agencies handpick products tailored to their public persona. Bloggers, meanwhile, command tight-knit communities of followers drawn to their perceived expertise, anchored on dedicated publishing platforms that deliver sustained search traffic. If their brand page is substantial, advertising returns multiply accordingly.
Then there are personal Facebook profiles without dedicated fan pages, who amass thousands of (mostly male) friends simply by posting attractive selfies. (I refer to them as “Facebook users” because their true identities might even be completely fictitious.) The audience dynamic here is the exact opposite of traditional bloggers, and calling them celebrities is an absurd stretch. (If having friends makes you a celebrity, my nearly 2,000 Facebook friends make me half a celebrity—feel free to send a friend request!) Why on earth do brand marketers believe hiring these personal profiles to promote skincare and cosmetic treatments will generate meaningful commercial conversion?
Most male friends following these accounts (myself included) are there solely to look at flattering photos (many of which are stolen from elsewhere) and melancholy musings—which routinely garner inflated like counts. But when it comes to what facial toner or serum she supposedly used to look this radiant, nobody really cares. It’s like wanting an attractive girlfriend without caring about the surgical procedures behind her appearance—men generally only look at the end result.
On my own Facebook feed, one user reached the maximum cap of 5,000 friends. A few days ago, she posted an ultimatum announcing a purge of inactive friends, urging anyone who wanted to stay to leave a reaction (a behavior extensively studied in social psychology). That ultimatum garnered barely 600 likes. The vast majority of people—at least 4,400 out of 5,000—dislike and ignore such manufactured threats, proving it to be completely ineffective audience motivation.
Predictably, two days later she published a sponsored post promoting cute Japanese eye drops (which likely violated pharmaceutical advertising regulations). The post received fewer than 70 likes, roughly 90% of which were from men—the same guys who would smash the like button if she simply posted a crying emoji. Not a single person in that 90% demographic represents a prospective buyer for decorative eye drops, nor will they share the post (owing to the possessive male instinct that prefers keeping attractive profiles to themselves). Had that exact same promotional budget been allocated to a legitimate beauty fan page, legions of young women would have shared it while tagging their friends in the comments.
Targeting the appropriate advertising channel has always been one of the foundational tenets of marketing.
That said, because the audience surrounding these personal profiles possesses a highly concentrated demographic profile, leveraging this dynamic creatively can occasionally yield surprising results. For instance, media personality “Chicken Cutlet Girl” (Ili Cheng) successfully sold life-size body pillows tailored specifically to dedicated male fans. Alternatively, framing these influencers as tech-savvy enthusiasts to promote consumer gadgets might yield far better ROI than pitching cosmetic clinic packages.
Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights
Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.
Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.
Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account




Comments