Cal Peternell, chef at Chez Panisse—often hailed as one of America’s finest restaurants—and author of Twelve Recipes, concluded after more than a decade in high-caliber professional kitchens that three ubiquitous kitchen tools simply have no business being in a kitchen. He has expressed genuine bewilderment over why so many people remain attached to them.

Those with a genuine passion for cooking often take pleasure in investing in kitchen gadgets and culinary gear. We tell ourselves that to do good work, one must sharpen their tools first—giving people of all stripes a convenient excuse to splurge.

Chez Panisse

If you share this tendency, you have likely encountered this familiar scenario: after happily bringing home a new kitchen gadget, you use it once or twice before quietly "**banishing**" it to the darkest depths of your cabinetry, never to be seen again until the annual spring cleaning.

In my own history of kitchen purchases, a heart-shaped silicone ice cube tray from IKEA probably stands as the most recent embarrassing example.

Below are the three tools that Cal Peternell insists should be kicked out of the kitchen:

  1. Glass cutting boards
  2. Serrated chef’s knives
  3. Garlic presses

1. Glass Cutting Boards

I once owned a glass cutting board. It was a gift from a friend; upon receiving it, I thought it looked gorgeous—clear, shiny, and sleek. But since my kitchen was already equipped with separate dedicated boards for raw and cooked ingredients, I tucked this gift away in a cupboard. It wasn’t until an old board finally wore out that I remembered this emblem of friendship.

Yet the moment my cherished chef’s knife struck that glass surface for the very first time, my heart sank. A glass board theoretically won’t score from blade marks and resists bacterial harbor, making it sound ideal on paper. However, glass holds a Mohs hardness of around 6.5. Kitchen knives, depending on their steel alloy, forging, and tempering, generally fall around a Mohs hardness of 5.5. This means that every single chop onto a glass board acts as an abrasive assault—and perpendicular to the delicate edge, which is the most destructive angle possible.

Furthermore, an ultra-hard, slick surface means the blade easily slips and slides, especially during slicing or precision cuts. This compromises blade stability and significantly increases the risk of accidental hand injuries.

2. Serrated Chef’s Knives

Cal observed that whether sold in sets or individually, serrated blades seem increasingly trendy. For bread knives or vegetable peelers, serration is indeed a brilliant design. Compared to a plain straight edge, a serrated peeler felt like a revelation, especially when tackling smooth potato skins where the micro-teeth provide superior grip and stability.

However, a serrated chef’s knife? Knife makers really should spare themselves the manufacturing effort. A serrated edge might easily pierce tomato skin to produce thin slices, but what you genuinely need is a razor-sharp, straight-edged chef’s knife.

A knife that cannot be sharpened on a whetstone is an ongoing disaster in any kitchen. You shouldn’t fear a sharp knife; what you should dread is a dull knife that mangles ingredients and demands excessive downward force, making you far more prone to slipping and slicing your own fingers.

3. Garlic Presses

The garlic press is a gadget that leaves Cal Peternell thoroughly perplexed: the garlic crushed through a press comes out too fine and wet for standard stir-frying, yet not quite a true "**puree**" for marinades and uncooked dressings.

The sole purpose of a garlic press is to crush garlic cloves into pulp.

When it comes to garlic presses, I don’t entirely share Cal’s frustration. In fact, it has been one of the few genuinely useful gadgets I’ve acquired recently (far more useful than that heart-shaped silicone ice tray). At the very least, it comes in handy whenever I’m preparing an olive oil vinaigrette or whipping up dipping sauces. While mincing garlic with a knife isn’t difficult, the thought of pulling out and washing another prep board often triggers sheer laziness—and that is where the press saves the day (though it would be even better if it peeled the garlic too).

Further Reading
  1. Source article: 3 Tools You Don’t Need In Your Kitchen.
  2. Cal Peternell’s cookbook: Twelve Recipes.
  3. Kitchen Tools: Garlic press product reference links.
✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account