This article continues from the previous piece, Insurance Claims / My Complete Record of Claim Appeals Against Shin Kong Insurance (Part II). At 4:31 PM on the same afternoon, a phone call from 02-7709103x rang on my cell phone.

Seeing this number, I figured it was finally time for the claims specialist, Mr. Chen, to call in person. Answering the phone, the voice on the other end was unfamiliar; the man simply introduced himself as an adjuster from Shin Kong Insurance, offering no further introduction. This call lasted a total of 12 minutes and 42 seconds.

The discussion with the adjuster largely revolved around the crux of differing perceptions on claims between both parties.

In fact, as mentioned in the first part, the reason I originally went in person to the Shin Kong Insurance office on Wenlin North Road to apply was specifically to monitor the progress of the entire application.

Issues arising from “differences in mutual understanding” in insurance have sparked major disputes all around the world for ages. I am neither the first nor will I be the last.

More than a decade ago, there was a manga titled Master Keaton, whose protagonist was an accident investigator for an international insurance company. His job took him worldwide to verify the authenticity of reported accidents, reporting his findings back to the British headquarters to serve as reference for the claims department during evaluations. Discrepancies in perception or interpretation appeared frequently throughout the series. Anyone interested can pick up a set to keep; it’s a great manga (its primary storyline revolves around adventure).

Back to the topic.

I confirmed with the claims adjuster that there were zero cognitive disputes regarding the items backed by medical receipts—everything was clearly written in black and white. However, the discrepancies regarding transportation expenses and medical assistive devices were enormous.

As for the home care nursing fees, he shirked responsibility by claiming they never received the application documents I submitted.

Andy Lau - Even God is furious

Should Bigman continue to remain gentle, modest, and courteous today?

I asked the adjuster: “I received the SMS notification from your company regarding the claim, and the disbursement amount was only 3,xxx NTD. Yet home nursing care alone amounts to 36,000 NTD. May I ask why there is such a massive discrepancy?”

The claims adjuster answered: “Because caregiver expenses can only be claimed during hospitalization.”

Hearing this explanation come out of his mouth, only one thought flashed through my mind: “Shin Kong Insurance truly has such a ‘professional’ adjuster, and Shin Kong Insurance truly has such a ‘trustworthy’ internal training system.”

Except right after that “good” should be appended: “Good my foot.”

I had no choice but to remind this professional adjuster once again: “Legally speaking, caregiver expenses include care provided by family members at home.”

Only then did he seem to wake up from a dream, explaining: “Oh, so you took care of him yourselves? That can be claimed too.”

“What kind of nonsense is that? If we didn’t hire a professional caregiver and didn’t have family take care of him, was an elderly person with impaired mobility supposed to hop around on his own? Or should we have asked that Zhuwei Junior High School teacher who caused the traffic violation accident to come nurse him?” — This was merely the shout inside my head.

From the start, I had personally invested time, prepared the documentation, and traveled to Shin Kong Insurance’s Shilin office to apply by hand, delivering and clarifying all materials upfront.

Andy Lau - Even God is furious Absolutely furious!

After using superhuman patience over the phone to ask this adjuster, Mr. Chen, to “re-examine” and “carefully” read my application, he finally “discovered” that I had indeed applied for home nursing care expenses from the very beginning.

Fuck you.

I understand that every claims adjuster has a massive caseload demanding urgent processing, and an individual cannot remember every detail of every file. Having handled mounds of legal case dockets myself, I sympathize with the difficulty of juggling countless facts.

However, when a client calls with an inquiry, at the very least I would pull up the file and review the contents while conversing. Even if stumped by something in the moment, one should never make such an utterly clueless fool of oneself.

Insurance practitioners, remember: you are handling legal matters; you must be accountable for every word that leaves your mouth!

If you only start grasping the situation after the client reminds you repeatedly, I seriously doubt whether your entire corporate culture deserves any trust. Yes, Shin Kong Insurance, I am talking about you!

In any case, once adjuster Mr. Chen finally understood the case situation—and after I reiterated that proof of home nursing care had been delivered by registered mail to Shin Kong Insurance’s Shilin branch—the adjuster actually claimed: “We didn’t receive the caregiver verification documents you sent. Could you send them again?”

I personally think Shin Kong Insurance adjusters are remarkably adept at testing policyholders’ breaking points.

Hearing this unreasonable request from Mr. Chen, the last drop of goodwill in my heart sank into the abyss. I calmly replied: “I have already sent formal legal documents containing ID copies, signed and sealed, via double-registered post to your company, and confirmed your office signed for them. I have no problem sending another copy, but if you cannot verify where my previous letter went, your company will face legal liabilities.”

Silence.

After hearing my flat, calm tone, adjuster Mr. Chen hesitated on the line for a few seconds. Then came a barrage of apologies, urgently asking me to hold on while he immediately searched for the postal documents, promising to call right back.

“What a complete 180 in attitude,” the voice in my head remarked.

At that moment, however, I told him to pause his search, because there were still two other accounts to settle with Shin Kong Insurance: transportation expenses and medical assistive equipment.

I asked Mr. Chen to give a verbal breakdown of how the claim came out to a mere 3,xxx NTD. Surprisingly, after that brief fright, he had become far more compliant.

Hearing his formal explanation, I learned that besides omitting the 36,000 NTD due to claimed missing nursing documents, this supposedly professional adjuster Mr. Chen had also arbitrarily slashed the transportation expenses for 9 hospital trips (18 total journeys) during the recovery period down to just 4 trips.

Well, well. Can a bone fracture heal in just four trips? Even Black Jack from Japan would be thoroughly impressed.

Shin Kong Insurance had also “automatically” ignored our claim for medical assistive equipment—all done unilaterally by adjuster Mr. Chen without prior notice or communication.

I told the adjuster: “I understand that calculations for transportation costs may vary in perception depending on district and distance, so I won’t nitpick over minor discrepancies. But you cannot arbitrarily slash 18 trips down to 4. Isn’t this kind of underhanded tampering absurd? Furthermore, the number of visits is easily verifiable directly from hospital receipts.”

After listening, the adjuster merely promised to help calculate the fare for the remaining 14 trips.

In the end, it turns out Shin Kong Insurance claims adjusters don’t actually calculate anything for you. They merely take the documents on hand—ignoring substance, tallying only surface figures, adding and subtracting—and call it a day.

More crucially, when I initially submitted the application hoping they would calculate the claim rigorously, they patted their chests guaranteeing that basic claim calculations were their core professional expertise. Yet in the end, it was their own professional staff who undermined the firm’s credibility.

My conclusion from observing this is: adjusters might verify what documents you’ve submitted, but they will only act upon what is visibly right in front of their eyes.

The moment an adjuster overlooks a document, or even documents previously agreed to be unnecessary (like taxi receipts in this instance) which you trusted them on and omitted, they seem to think it is entirely your own problem if you fail to receive proper compensation—because adjusters will never actively fight for your rightful, basic entitlements.

At least, that was precisely the case in this claim handled by Shin Kong Insurance following the traffic violation caused by Teacher Chien of Zhuwei Junior High School.

By the way, regarding the 400 NTD claim for medical assistive equipment, I decided not to argue further. When my father was struck by Teacher Chien’s traffic violation and sent to the hospital, I hadn’t asked the physician to explicitly write a prescription for crutches on the diagnosis certificate (in truth, most doctors nowadays wouldn’t bother writing such obvious remarks). Without explicit black-and-white phrasing, I couldn’t be bothered to squabble.

Particularly when the “expert” inside an insurance firm cannot even fathom why someone recovering from a leg injury needs crutches, I doubt he possesses the capacity to understand the point of contention anyway.

I gently hung up the phone and waited for the adjuster to locate the registered documents they had misplaced.

At 4:55 PM, just 2 minutes and 15 seconds later, Mr. Chen called back. This time, he found the nursing documentation I had mailed with remarkable speed, followed by repeated apologies over the phone.

I asked him to expedite the process, laid down my card, and ended this round of today’s conversation.

On December 7, 2012, at 11:26 AM, Mr. Chen finally called again; this time the call lasted 8 minutes.

The main purpose of his call was to notify me that he calculated transportation expenses at roughly 2,000 NTD. This was still substantially short of my calculation of 3,440 (-860) + 316, totaling 2,896 NTD (with 860 NTD being the 4 trips already paid)—a gap equivalent to 15 bento boxes in popular netizen parlance.

Initially, I assumed his calculation method differed from mine. But after some discussion, I realized his single-trip fare was identical to mine, both calculated according to Taipei Taxi Association tariff tables.

Why did a gap of nearly 900 NTD persist between our totals? The discrepancy stemmed entirely from the adjuster calculating only (X-4)*2 days of trips for my father’s hospital visits. Meanwhile, I insisted the total transportation count should be 2X-4 trips (where 4 represents the one-way trips already compensated). What kind of bizarre mathematics calculates (X-4)*2?

Bigman’s friendly tip: No matter how poor your math skills are, you can still become a claims adjuster at Shin Kong Insurance.

Finally, adjuster Mr. Chen relented under my relentless demand for mathematical rigor.

He explained that the reason for this odd calculation was that he had previously filed for four trips, and Shin Kong Insurance’s flawed computer system directly registered that “4” as four full days of transportation expenses, closing them out.

In other words, he could no longer submit the missing return trips for those four days to his supervisor for approval. (God knows how a Shin Kong Insurance adjuster can use such an excuse to stonewall an affected policyholder.)

However, the adjuster knew how to negotiate this time. Recognizing my insistence on accurate data, he adopted a humble posture: “Actually, even if we resubmit this transportation claim, our supervisor might not sign off since you provided almost no receipts initially. But I’ll do my best to plead your case with management.”

To my ears, the subtext was: “If you keep nickel-and-diming, you might not get a single cent. I’m helping you out right now, so don’t be troublesome.”

Mr. Chen probably didn’t realize how much I love fiction tropes. I immediately retorted: “Then tell me which dates are missing, and I will find a way to produce receipts.”

The unspoken message: “If you fail to get this approved, everyone is going to have a hard time.”

Several days passed after hanging up without Mr. Chen reaching out again.

Finally, I received another SMS confirming the claim approval. Sure enough, it was still short by the 896 NTD I insisted upon—meaning 15 fewer bento boxes.

In the future, if I ever purchase insurance from Shin Kong Insurance again, or let my children, relatives, or friends attend Zhuwei Junior High School, I will write my name backward from right to left.

Reader Q&A and Practical Property Claim Countermeasures (Selected Historical Digest)

Following the publication of this bitter chronicle of car accident insurance claim disputes, it resonated strongly with countless victimized vehicle owners and their families. Facts have proven that among property insurers like Shin Kong Insurance, “delaying whenever possible, slashing amounts, claiming documents were lost, and concealing itemized calculations” have long been unwritten industry standards.

Compiled below by Bigman are genuine accounts from readers over the years along with battle-tested solutions:


1. Two-Thirds Slashed in a Black Box? Why Won’t They Disclose the Breakdown? (Reader Waiting for Claim Breakdown)

Reader Waiting for Claim Breakdown asks:
I asked the claims adjuster for an itemized calculation sheet of the payout. The adjuster stalled, saying it would take 3 to 7 days, but after waiting more than a month, there was nothing! The final approved amount was maliciously slashed by a full two-thirds! Whom should I request this breakdown from? Do I file a complaint with the same adjuster?

Bigman’s Professional Analysis:
This is the insurer’s textbook “black-box claim slashing playbook”:

  1. Why they refuse to give breakdowns: Their internal review principle is “slash whatever can be slashed.” The adjuster unilaterally removes diagnostic certificates, self-paid medications, caregiver fees, or transit fares without any solid legal basis for deduction. Once laid out on paper, proof of illegal, arbitrary cuts is exposed instantly; hence, they will stall and refuse disclosure by any means.
  2. Counter-strategy: Once all claim documents are submitted, under Article 131 of the Insurance Act, insurers must pay within the agreed period or within 15 days of receiving notice and full supporting documents. When demanding a breakdown, don’t be polite—issue an ultimatum: “If you do not provide the deduction items and statutory grounds in writing within three days, a complaint will be immediately filed with the Financial Ombudsman Institution.” Never fall for stalling tactics like “I will try to fight for you.”

2. “Two Rings and Hang Up” to Fake Contact Logs? Beware of the Six-Month Criminal Statute of Limitations! (Readers Waiting for Claim Breakdown & Jian Kunji)

Experiences of Readers Waiting for Claim Breakdown & Jian Kunji:

  • Waiting for Claim Breakdown: After waiting almost two months, the adjuster called back claiming they called yesterday but the victim didn’t answer! In fact, the victim was working right beside the phone, and it only rang 1 to 3 times before hanging up! Rechecking the bills later, ENT fees for vertigo were completely dropped without consent, excused by “the documents aren’t with the auditor.”
  • Jian Kunji: Submitted complete files to Shin Kong Insurance in Chiayi in late 2018, met with constant delays and nitpicking. Only after filing a complaint in March 2019 did the adjuster claim over 70,000 NTD was approved, yet continued delaying payout after approval!

Bigman’s Incisive Counterattack:

  • Despicable “Fake Contact Record” tactic: Letting the phone ring twice and hanging up is a sleazy trick used by substandard agents to fulfill internal customer follow-up metrics. The system logs “contacted on date X,” shifting blame onto the policyholder for “no answer” to justify case delays.
  • The deadly six-month trap: In accidents involving personal injury, the statute of limitations for filing criminal charges of negligent injury is only six months! If the insurance company uses a “delaying tactic” past six months, the victim loses criminal leverage to compel civil settlement, and the insurer’s civil settlement stance instantly turns ruthless and uncompromising.
  • Bigman Warns: If more than 15 business days pass after submitting full documents without clear progress, immediately initiate external grievance procedures. Never let them run out your valuable statutory window.

Reader Waiting for Claim Breakdown is confused:
The adjuster actually told me over the phone to “contact the counterparty directly for certification.” What does that even mean?

Bigman Sternly Refutes:
This is simply the adjuster taking advantage of policyholders unfamiliar with legal regulations, trying to pull a vanishing act:

  • Whether Compulsory Auto Liability or Third-Party Liability Insurance: Victims possess direct claim rights by statute or contract. Verifying liability, checking police transcripts, or seeking subrogation against the at-fault driver is an internal relationship between the insurer and its insured policyholder, having nothing to do with the victim!
  • The victim only needs to provide the Traffic Accident Party Registration Slip / Preliminary Analysis Notice and their own medical receipts. Demanding that the victim run after the at-fault party for proof is pure obstruction and evasion. Bluntly tell the adjuster that their demand has no basis in law.

4. Internal Customer Service Protects Its Own! The Only Solution: Target the Financial Ombudsman Institution (Readers TONY & Waiting for Claim Breakdown)

Realization from Readers TONY & Waiting for Claim Breakdown:

  • TONY: Shin Kong’s attitude was terrible, completely indifferent. Filing a complaint leads nowhere; no matter how you complain to headquarters, the case gets dumped back to the original handler, forever stuck!
  • Waiting for Claim Breakdown: I should go directly to the Financial Ombudsman Institution. They lost the paperwork, they made the mistakes, there’s no reason to accommodate them. Filing for ombudsman dispute resolution is vastly more effective than waiting fruitlessly!

Bigman’s Definitive Solution Guide:
This is the golden rule we emphasize time and again—do not waste time on an insurance company’s internal complaint channels!

  1. Internal customer service is merely a firewall: The insurer’s grievance hotline exists to pacify and reassign, ultimately bouncing back to the original supervisor and case handler, forming a closed loop of self-protection.
  2. Go directly to the Financial Ombudsman Institution (supervised by the Financial Supervisory Commission):
    • If a written complaint to the insurer goes unresolved for over 30 days, or if the policyholder rejects their resolution, you may formally apply for dispute resolution with the “Financial Ombudsman Institution” within 60 days.
    • Insurance companies dread case audits from the Ombudsman Institution. Once docketed, the case enters the Insurance Bureau’s regulatory evaluation metrics, putting supervisors under scrutiny and adjusters at risk of disciplinary action. Once the ombudsman procedure is initiated, previously obstructive adjusters often come knocking within days, offering full compensation settlements!

Further Reading

  1. Insurance Claims / My Complete Record of Claim Appeals Against Shin Kong Insurance (Part I)
  2. Insurance Claims / My Complete Record of Claim Appeals Against Shin Kong Insurance (Part II)
✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account