At 20:59 on October 26, 2012, a text message arrived from “091151026x” on behalf of Shin Kong Insurance: “Dear valued customer: Regarding the auto insurance claim for license plate CHJ-25x, our company deposited the compensation of 3,xxx NTD into your designated account on November 26, 2012. Please check your account. Sincerely, Shin Kong Insurance.”

This SMS was the payout notification for a compulsory motorcycle liability insurance claim I had submitted to Shin Kong Insurance. The dispute originated when my father was wrongfully caught in a traffic accident, which fractured his tibia.

The circumstances of the crash were rather bizarre. The driver at fault was a teacher named Chien from Zhuwei Junior High School. She was driving in violation of traffic regulations (carrying two children on her scooter, severely compromising driving safety—it truly baffles me how such a person could be an educator), grazed an elderly man’s scooter, and then hurtled forward nearly ten meters before crashing straight into my father, who was standing peacefully on the sidewalk.

Upon receiving the text, my immediate reaction was to jump online to look up customer service contact numbers for Shin Kong Insurance.

Shin Kong Insurance’s homepage provided three phone numbers: 02-25075335, claims hotline 0800-789-999, and complaints hotline 0800-005-588.

I dialed the toll-free claims hotline first. After all, it was already 10 PM; Shin Kong’s headquarters certainly wouldn’t have dedicated staff on duty, but I figured their claims desk would operate 24 hours.

Sure enough, after a few rings, a gentleman answered on the other end.

I said into the receiver: “Hello sir, I just received an SMS from your company stating that the claim amount has been deposited into my account. However, the amount you sent is completely incorrect.”

The phone representative from Shin Kong’s claims desk (hereafter referred to as the representative) replied: “Are you referring to compulsory insurance?”

I hesitated for a second, having not immediately recalled the formal policy title. Glancing at the prepared documents beside me, I answered: “Yes, that’s right—compulsory motorcycle liability insurance.”

After the representative pulled up the case file, I bypassed most minor expense items and asked directly: “Just the statutory benefit for home nursing care alone is fundamentally NT$36,000. Why did your company only disburse a little over three thousand!?”

The point of my call wasn’t to resolve fine details that require paper documentation, but rather to politely yet unambiguously convey: “It was bad enough that my father was hit and injured by a Zhuwei Junior High teacher, and now you have made matters worse by botching the payout. I am thoroughly displeased.”

Andy Lau - Even gods get angryWhen politeness runs dry…

Following my “effective communication,” unsurprisingly, the representative was left completely speechless. All he could say was: “Since the adjuster handling this case is a Mr. Chen, I will have him call you tomorrow”—another utterly predictable response.

I replied, “Fine, thank you,” and hung up.

After hanging up, I looked up the websites of the Financial Supervisory Commission (FSC) and the Financial Ombudsman Institution (FOI; consumer complaint hotline 0800-789-885) and bookmarked them. Having previously engaged in a high-stakes duel with a district manager from Nan Shan Life that felt like a spy thriller, I knew well which regulatory bodies would come in handy.

Next, I dialed Shin Kong Insurance’s complaint hotline. As expected, an automated recording greeted me: “These are non-business hours. Please call back during regular business hours. Beep… beep… beep…”

With the claim documents organized and the grievance escalation channels lined up, that concluded matters for the night.

Tomorrow I will have a thorough chat with this Mr. Chen—assuming the sun rises from the west and he actually takes the initiative to call. Otherwise, lacking his direct contact info, I will proceed straight to the formal complaint line.

I later wrote to the FSC regarding this matter, inquiring how general consumers should handle such discrepancy situations to properly safeguard their legitimate rights. Otherwise, insurers retain unchecked control over the claims process from beginning to end—a status quo inherently unfair to consumers. We were already victimized by a reckless Zhuwei Junior High teacher; having to battle bureaucratic resistance for basic compensation is absurd. Once the FSC issues an official reply, I will publish it verbatim below in hopes of helping others who face similar predicaments.

Reader Q&A

How to Counter When the At-Fault Party Vanishes and the Insurer Stalls or Falsifies Contact Logs? (Reader: Heavy Rain)

Reader Heavy Rain asks:
This was incredibly helpful! In March, a driver insured by this company made an illegal right turn at a prohibited intersection and crashed into my family member’s scooter, damaging the vehicle and sending the rider to the hospital. Afterwards, although the insurance company never reached out to us once, their system actually had the audacity to record “Contacted”! To this day, no three-way discussion has taken place. All parties are working professionals. After finally aligning our schedules to meet the adjuster, the adjuster kept stalling. Good grief… I will share our subsequent outcome for everyone’s reference.

Bigman’s Incisive Analysis:
This playbook—where “the perpetrator throws up their hands and dumps everything onto the insurer, while the adjuster plays dead, stalls, or even falsifies internal logs”—is precisely the most common stalling tactic faced by traffic accident victims in Taiwan Province!

Dealing with this is undeniably draining, but when handling non-life insurers and evasive tortfeasors, Bigman recommends keeping the following strategic rules firmly in mind:

  1. Never fall into the passive trap of “waiting on the adjuster’s schedule”:
    The claims adjuster is a salaried employee whose KPIs often incentivize dragging things out, chipping away at amounts, and waiting for exhausted victims to capitulate. Working professionals have day jobs and must care for the injured at night; you cannot afford the time cost, nor should you let the adjuster lead you by the nose.
  2. Firmly wield the criminal leverage: the “six-month statute of limitations for negligent injury”:
    In traffic accidents involving physical injury, the statutory window to file a criminal complaint for “negligent injury” under criminal law is a brief 6 months! Many insurers exploit scheduling excuses precisely to stall past the six-month mark. Once you forfeit criminal leverage, the other party becomes far more arrogant regarding civil damages. If the deadline approaches and the other party demonstrates no good faith, do not hesitate: go straight to the handling police precinct to file a formal complaint for negligent injury, and let the prosecutor summon the tortfeasor to the investigation room!
  3. Escalate to supervisory regulators to break the stalemate:
    If the insurer falsifies internal logs or manufactures delays, compile your call records and file formal complaints directly with the Financial Ombudsman Institution and the Insurance Bureau of the FSC. Once the FOI accepts a case, headquarters’ legal department must submit a written reply within a strict timeframe, and frontline adjusters will no longer dare to drag their feet.

You have endured immense hardship caring for your family’s recovery and fighting for their rights. Hang in there! Wishing your family member a swift recovery, and looking forward to hearing your victorious report!


Further Reading

  1. Insurance Claims / Full Record of Traffic Accident Claim Dispute with Shin Kong Insurance (Part 2)
  2. Insurance Claims / Full Record of Traffic Accident Claim Dispute with Shin Kong Insurance (Part 3)
✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account