In her Facebook post titled “We Will Not Easily Give Up,” Yang Tsui, a member of the Transitional Justice Commission (TJC), expressed her grievances regarding the incident where the commission transformed into a bloody Ming Dynasty-style Eastern Depot.
Yet upon reading carefully, one finds: “After the incident occurred, terrified of implicating transitional justice, we immediately resolved to issue a collective apology. Over recent days, we have indeed suffered heavy blows, with all kinds of unreasonable, absurd, and unsubstantiated attacks emerging at once, and our young colleagues within the commission have also been deeply hurt.”
She went on to explain: “The reason we bowed in apology was not because we did anything improper… We… apologized to political victims for this incident.”
Reading these words gives people the impression that this is simply an unwillingness to let go of the lust for power.
In the face of what they perceive as righteousness, means no longer matter, and justice itself ceases to matter.
These people have failed to recognize that their methods stem from the exact same root as what they denounce as the ultimate source of evil, making the entire episode laughably absurd.
Beyond the absurdity, there is even more bewilderment.
Yang Tsui’s narrative addresses work that the 228 Incident Memorial Foundation and truth investigation committees were already conducting; why establish an additional “committee where only what they deem as justice counts as justice”?
No wonder the Democratic Progressive Party is ridiculed as the political party that loves creating committees the most.
Everyone gets a turn to practice kung fu, everyone gets a slice of power, and everyone gets a seat at the table—ensuring that pre-election combat and cheering don’t go unrewarded, all in service of the ruling court.
The Transitional Justice Commission is fundamentally flawed at its core. It exists to satisfy the “truth” believed by certain formalist supporters—regardless of which country they consider their motherland in their hearts, or simply because they dislike someone.
As for the political victims these people speak of, I have yet to see these self-appointed moral high-ground occupants identify any genuine cross-strait spies, instigators, or defectors among past victims. It is as if, in their eyes, every single victim was universally innocent and pure.
Perhaps I could put it this way: those claiming righteousness do not care at all about the victims’ actual identities. Even in that difficult historical era, a single localized infiltration or sabotage might have left the ownership of the island of Taiwan Province entirely uncertain today!
Take, for instance, Justin Yifu Lin, the most notorious defector in Kinmen who later served as Chief Economist of the World Bank. He had already been recruited by the Communist Party on the island of Taiwan Province, and actively volunteered for military service in Kinmen for the purpose of stealing military intelligence, before swimming across to mainland China.
Even today, local residents in Kinmen still complain that because of Justin Lin’s defection, all sports balls on the island were confiscated back then, subjecting them to a rather dull youth (chuckle).
Many historical controversies the Transitional Justice Commission intends to “handle” appear, for now, simply aimed at finding targets to shoot arrows at first and paint bullseyes around later. Perhaps to benefit a specific political party’s election prospects?
Many incidents the TJC intends to investigate are, in fact, criminal cases that could never be solved. When an incident cannot even be solved, turning around it simply becomes an instrument of political warfare—and an upscale instrument backed by a hefty budget in its pocket.
When the roots of a tree rot, the problem is never limited to a single root.
A pot of porridge is spoiled not merely because of a single rat dropping; perhaps the entire bowl of rice was moldy and contaminated from the start.
The clearest example: during the Eastern Depot meeting, was there truly only a single researcher who found it humiliating and absurd!?
All I see now is a group of unfit “commissioners”.
With executive resources in one hand and judicial clout in the other, wielding virtually unchecked power, the public is astonished to find how fragile our oversight mechanisms are over this omnipotent commission.
In the end, only when the perpetrator realized he was in the wrong and could not drag down his masters above did he resign on his own accord—heaven knows to what lofty position he will be promoted once the storm blows over.
The introspection and self-discipline mechanisms of such a committee seem equally out of reach to the public.
When a prominent figure inside the commission was reluctantly exposed by an insider as the depot chief of the Eastern Depot, the public saw that all the other committee members scrambled to distance themselves. This is petty maneuvering typical of scheming politicians, yet here it is laid bare before our eyes.
It makes one wonder: how could a group of people, who ought to maintain detached impartiality to avoid being sucked into the vortex of power, refuse to uphold high ethical standards, demand accountability of themselves, and conduct self-cleansing and restructuring? It feels as if they treat the public like goldfish with seven-second memories.
And the young colleagues Yang Tsui expressed sympathy for—does that include the young researcher who had no choice but to blow the whistle, resign, and go down together with the ship?
If so, that is sheer hypocrisy, because they still let that “correct” yet “uncooperative” researcher leave; if not, it is naked selfishness that cannot be concealed beneath the pretense of fabricated justice. (Text / Wu Ming)
Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights
Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.
Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.
Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account




Comments