Gutter oil, an unsettling term originating from mainland China, refers to illicit waste oil collected by unscrupulous merchants recycling food scraps and discarded cooking grease from street stalls and restaurants, decaying animal viscera from slaughterhouses, and chemical waste oil from tanneries.

Leveraging basic chemical processing tricks, these unethical operators mix all kinds of rancid waste oils together. Through refining and bleaching, the concoction is magically transformed into what outwardly resembles normal cooking oil, but is secretly laden with toxic molecules, heavy metals, and potent carcinogens—a truly toxic oil.

As news anchors and journalists across Taiwan have reported extensively in recent days, Chang Guann Enterprise Co., located in Daliao District, Kaohsiung City, not only blended inferior gutter oil into their flagship “Chuan Tung Fragrant Lard,” but also shipped nearly a thousand metric tons (Updated Sept 9, 2014: 782 metric tons) of tainted oil to more than 235 midstream vendors across Taiwan—including wholesale distributors, food manufacturers, and restaurant chains. Through secondary distribution and food processing, these midstream vendors further dispersed this toxic oil across over 1,000 downstream retailers (Updated Sept 9, 2014: 1,020 vendors). The sheer reach and speed of this distribution network sends chills down one’s spine.

Still, we have to find a bit of dark humor in life: care to guess whether the three prominent brands flagged by the authorities—“Mei & Mei”, “Yu Jen Jai”, and “Kong Yen”—are actually the household names you have in mind? I will reveal the answer at the end of the post.

Below is the official press release from the Food and Drug Administration (TFDA), explaining ongoing testing into the chemical makeup of these contaminated oils:

TFDA Press Release:

Clarification on the Investigation into Chang Guann’s Manufacturing and Sale of Substandard Lard [Release Date: 2014-09-05]

The Food and Drug Administration… mobilized inspection forces to inspect night markets, eateries, food stores, and ingredient distributors. As of 10:00 AM on September 5, 2014, a total of 120 kg and 360,491 cans of related products were sealed. Within Chang Guann’s manufacturing plant, 44,632 kg of “Chuan Tung Fragrant Lard” remained in stock and was fully impounded. Currently, 320 barrels (~5,120 kg) have been recalled, with recall operations actively ongoing. Simultaneously, an inventory audit of Chang Guann Co.’s records revealed that 235 downstream vendors may have received suspected contaminated raw oil materials…

…Under Article 7 of the Act Governing Food Safety and Sanitation, …violators face a maximum administrative fine of NT$3 million under Article 47. Manufacturers using “Chuan Tung Fragrant Lard” as an ingredient must immediately report product names, specifications, batch numbers, expiration dates, and quantities to their local health bureaus, proactively initiate product recalls, and report recalled numbers. Severe penalties will be imposed on those who fail to comply. Furthermore, official testing methodologies for heavy metals (lead, cadmium, mercury, copper, tin), aflatoxins, benzo[a]pyrene, and acid values have been established, and TFDA-accredited laboratories are conducting verifications. Industry operators are urged to fulfill their responsibilities for self-regulation.

Following amendments to the Act Governing Food Safety and Sanitation, whistle-blower reward allocation rates were substantially raised from 5% to 10% of total fines. Informants who provide evidence leading to the discovery of violations will be rewarded…

In this case, operators found guilty of fraud through the use of substandard oils face fines up to NT$50 million under the food safety law; severe offenses may result in business suspension or revocation, and criminal charges for fraud will be pursued under the Criminal Code. The Administration reiterates that unethical businesses causing major harm will face the most stringent penalties.

While the press release sounds resolute, today word came out that the person in charge was released on bail for a mere NT$50,000 (sips hot tea).

Distribution Map of Affected Downstream Vendors Across Taiwan:

The victims of this scandal encompass distributors, food processors, catering services, and restaurants—totaling 235 direct midstream clients of Chang Guann (which further branched into 971 secondary downstream vendors). Many are well-known household food brands in Taiwan, such as Wei Chuan, Sheng Hsiang Jen (snacks, sweets, biscuits), Ve Wong (Prince Noodles, instant ramen), Taiwan Sugar Corporation (Taisun), Mei & Mei, Tiansongpi (Wei Zhen Xiang Fried Pork), Wu Hua Ma, Chi Mei (steamed buns, dumplings), Yu Jen Jai (historic bakery), Lee Hu (historic bakery), and Gourmet Master (85°C Bakery Cafe).

Among them are Fultons Food and Master Chuan (dumplings, potstickers), which supply Costco. This makes one wonder whether Costco will switch suppliers, given Costco’s notoriously rigorous vetting procedures.

Most alarmingly, even major upstream raw ingredient suppliers were caught in Chang Guann’s net—and that is the truly horrifying part! For example: Yi-Lin (supplying ketchup and black pepper sauces to fast-food chains and hypermarkets), Kaohsiung’s Wanglai Hsing (bulk bakery ingredient wholesaler), Pa Pa King / Bull Head brand (shacha hot-pot sauce), Tainan local ingredient suppliers Tang Ming and Hsin Yi, and Ching Hsiang, a major manufacturer of Donggang sailfish floss, mullet roe, and sakura shrimp.

These ingredient suppliers and food brands touch groceries that virtually everyone in Taiwan consumes on a daily basis, inflicting both tangible and subtle harm on our long-term health.

The map below plots all affected vendors across Taiwan. You can check whether any of these food manufacturers or restaurants are located near your home and take extra precautions over the coming days.

In the map, I used distinct icons based on the volume of substandard oil purchased: 1–99 barrels (map pin), 100–499 barrels (flask icon), 500–999 barrels (large oil drum), 1,000+ barrels (skull icon), and factory icons for employee group purchases at Chang Guann’s Kaohsiung headquarters and Taipei branch.

As for why employees themselves group-purchased these oils: were they kept in the dark as well, or did they buy them for family-run food stalls? That remains a sobering question.

Downstream Vendor List for Chang Guann’s “Chuan Tung Fragrant Lard”:

Due to the immense volume of data, please refer to references [1], [2], and [4] through [7] below. By the way, remember the question I posed at the beginning?

In truth, the “Mei & Mei” listed by the FDA is the corporate entity behind the “Good Morning! Mei Zhi Cheng” breakfast franchise, whereas the familiar “Mei & Mei Breakfast” chain is registered under “Jian Sheng.”

Similarly, there are two distinct entities named “Yu Jen Jai”: “Yu Jen Jai Food Co., Ltd.” and “Yu Jen Jai Food Enterprises Ltd.” The one implicated this time is the former, which operates the separate “Shi-Liang-Lu Bakery” storefront. In fact, we once wrote a marketing review for Shi-Liang-Lu: “Food Review: RoooRoo Shi-Liang-Lu Bakery’s Fortune & Longevity Pastries”—we certainly hope this crisis gets resolved swiftly.

Finally, regarding “Kong Yen”: did you immediately think of the iconic “Kong Yen Vinegar” like I did? In reality, the producer of Kong Yen Vinegar is registered as “Ta An Kong Yen Food Factory Co., Ltd.”

Ultimately, Chinese corporate naming is wonderfully diverse, yet somehow everyone ends up using the exact same monikers.

Company Profile: Chang Guann Enterprise Co., Ltd.

Kaohsiung Headquarters

  • Name: Chang Guann Enterprise Co., Ltd.
  • Phone: (07) 701-1333
  • Fax: (07) 701-5171
  • Address: No. 808, Sec. 1, Fengping 1st Rd., Daliao Dist., Kaohsiung City
  • Website: http://www.changguann.com.tw/
  • Legal Representative: Yeh Wen-Hsiang
  • Unified Business Number: 22965739
  • Paid-in Capital (NTD): 550,000,000
  • Approval Date: July 6, 1988
  • Registered Business Scope:
    • C105010 Edible Fats and Oils Manufacturing
    • F102020 Edible Fats and Oils Wholesale
    • C201010 Animal Feed Manufacturing
    • F103010 Animal Feed Wholesale
    • F111090 Building Materials Wholesale
    • F107170 Industrial Auxiliary Agents Wholesale
    • F401010 International Trade
    • ZZ99999 All legal business activities not prohibited or restricted by law

Board of Directors and Supervisors:

  • Chairman: Yeh Wen-Hsiang
  • Director: Mitsui & Co., Ltd. (Japan)
  • Director: Tsukishima Foods Industry Co., Ltd. (Japan)

Taipei Branch

  • Phone: (02) 2680-2768
  • Fax: (02) 2680-0706
  • Address: No. 2-7, Lane 135, Sec. 2, Xizhun St., Shulin Dist., New Taipei City
References & Appendix:
  1. List of 235 vendors released by the TFDA (Updated: Sept 5, 2014, 10:00 AM).
  2. Netizens compiled an open downstream vendor spreadsheet allowing the public and businesses to clarify information: “Link to Chang Guann Downstream Vendor Spreadsheet”.
  3. If there are any discrepancies in this post, official TFDA notices take precedence.
  4. Official data correction: 79 N3021 Employee purchase 130 New Taipei City, Shulin Dist., Sec. 2, Xizhun St., Lane 135, No. 2-7, Tel: 02-26800708.
  5. Official data correction: 57 N1362 Jih Hsiang 40 Miaoli County / Taoyuan County, Dayuan Township, Sec. 2, Sanmin Rd., No. 490, Tel: 03-3838779.
  6. Official data correction: 38 M2957 Chin Yuan Pao 150 Yunlin County, Huwei Township, No. 13-8 Hutouli, Tel: 0938651950. (Chin Yuan Pao clarified that their main plant did not procure oil from Chang Guann; it is suspected to be an independent franchisee action.)
  7. Official data correction: 175 S3443 Chien Yen-Hui 333 Pingtung City, No. 555, Longrong Li (Rd.), Tel: 7516687. (Note: Pingtung has no Longrong Li, but has Longhua Li; plotted as Longhua Li for now, pending official corrections.)
Supplementary Updates:
  • 2014.09.07: Chang Guann shipped a total of 51,981 barrels of Chuan Tung Fragrant Lard (~782 metric tons): 161 wholesale distributors (who resold to 971 downstream entities), 51 food manufacturers and restaurants, and 23 other entities (including private individuals).
  • 2014.09.08: Following health bureau audits, it is confirmed that Chang Guann supplied 235 midstream operators (782 tons / 51,981 barrels), reaching 1,012 downstream vendors. Authorities have traced 681 metric tons of tainted oil, sealing ~161 tons, with 208 suspect product lines identified (“List of 208 Questionable Products from Chang Guann Downstream Vendors”), and ~218 tons seized and recalled.
  • 2014.09.08: Supply chain trajectory: Waste recycled oil (Hu Hsin-Te plant) → Kuo Lieh-Cheng → Raw oil stock (Chang Guann) → Chuan Tung Fragrant Lard.
  • 2014.09.09: Health bureaus confirmed 235 midstream operators (782 tons / 51,981 barrels) branching into 1,020 downstream vendors. 703 metric tons accounted for, 161 tons sealed, 222 affected products identified (“20140909 Tainted Oil Downstream Retailers Product List”), and 228 metric tons pulled from shelves.
  • 2014.09.09: The “barrel” unit used by the health authorities equals 15 or 16 kg per drum.
✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account