With an increasing number of tourists flocking to Tamsui recently to admire, pet, and tease cats, speaking purely for myself, I genuinely do not wish to see Tamsui become a second Houtong.

Every stably developing ecosystem operates by its own set of intrinsic rules. When an ecosystem is subjected to artificial marketing, promotion, or shaped with the mindset of cultivating entertainment pop stars, the final outcome will be far worse than you can imagine. In Houtong, the reckoning arrived when outbreaks of feline distemper made headline news; it became the first place in Taiwan to confuse “natural ecosystems” with “tourism resources.”

Having cats in Tamsui is wonderful.

Yet, if Tamsui had no cats, what of it?

The scenario of having no cats actually splits into two categories: one where cats disappear due to malicious capture, and another where compassionate people take them home to live safe lives. If it is the latter, then I believe Tamsui having no cats on the streets would be marvelous.

However, I know that some individuals who have long taken an interest in Tamsui’s cat scene disagree with the idea of “Tamsui without cats.”

Setting aside whether these people cannot keep cats at home, wish to use them as promotional attractions for commercial ventures, or act out of pure compassionate care.

Street cats are now part of ecosystems across the globe (though in ecological terms, domestic cats and dogs are non-native species), and seeing so many people selflessly care for, feed, and watch over them is touching.

Yet if people come to believe they possess rights and moral authority over this local ecosystem, or treat street cats as temporary vanity pets or attractions, or turn feline habitats into platforms for alternative socializing, or exploit public goodwill as leverage, it reminds me of what author Chang Hui-ching wrote in Things You Don’t Believe: “I suddenly realized that what I had always called love was, without question, precisely my own malice.”

Just like the little street cat “Xiao Heishou” (Black Paws) we photographed by the Tamsui riverside parking lot, everything has two sides. But what is thrust into the limelight is by no means inherently more noble—that is mere human arrogance.

Tamsui riverside street cat Xiao Heishou

Tamsui street cat Xiao Heishou (Credits: Jinliang Lin)

As an aside, we observe an unwritten photography rule along the Tamsui riverfront: whenever two or more groups are already photographing on site, I only watch from afar, and if the crowd behaves without undue disruption, I quietly move on. Even when photographing cats ourselves, we adhere strictly to a threefold policy of no feeding, no calling out, and no teasing. The sole purpose is to minimize cats paying undue attention to humans.

Please do not forget: unless you bring them into your home to live together, they are bona fide wild animals. Even if people dress them up in romanticized bohemian jargon like “river cats” or “street cats,” it does not change the objective reality that they are stray animals.

The fact that I haven’t been able to take photos of riverside cats for quite some time now illustrates just how much tourist crowds have swelled recently. (Inner voice: Which explains why the current photos are older ones dragged out to fill the gallery.)

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account