Recently, an American short video titled “Teaching a Fish to Climb a Tree” has been widely shared and praised by many netizens. The video contends that modern school schooling is the primary factor holding back children throughout their lives, with sharing platforms self-servingly claiming it delivers penetrating insights that expose the systemic blind spots of modern education.

A friend of mine, having watched this video, was astonished and told me: “Finally someone has analyzed and pointed out the true cause. The school system really has serious problems.”

Is that truly the reality?

Let us first examine the student-faculty ratio at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) in the United States, which sits at roughly 1:7—meaning one faculty member for every seven students. Meanwhile, National Taiwan University (NTU) has a ratio closer to 1:12. This comparison shows that the faculty resource allocation at our country’s (the Republic of China) premier institution is only about half that of an elite American university. Simply looking at the raw numbers, our professors have to invest twice the effort to deliver an equivalent faculty-to-student dynamic.

Of course, I am not dismissing the valid point that “the school education system cannot cater to every child’s unique needs.” Yet one must recognize practical reality. Many online commenters today love to judge history through modern lenses, substituting critical complaining for constructive problem-solving, which is merely a waste of time learning how to escape reality.

Strictly speaking, modern schools were originally conceived as institutions designed to swiftly filter and produce “immediately deployable manpower,” while teaching basic literacy and fundamental knowledge to the rest along the way (spare me the grandiose ideals; I spent my academic youth constantly debating professors). For example, during the late Japanese colonial era in Taiwan, as Imperial Japan faced relentless setbacks in World War II, it suddenly expanded technical college enrollment to Taiwanese youths who were previously barred from entering, precisely so they could be dispatched directly to the frontlines. This functionalist educational model played a major historical role in modern institutional evolution, so the inability of mass schooling to cater to every single student’s idiosyncrasies is an understandable trade-off.

Moreover, primary and secondary schooling was never intended to turn you into an expert overnight. By providing broad general knowledge and basic common sense, it equips you with the fundamental tools to discover your own interests. That journey, however, is not something schools and teachers can arbitrarily mandate for you. Often, what truly limits you are your family environment, parental mindset, and your own courage and imagination.

You can argue that the school system did not nurture you individually, but you cannot argue that formal education fails to produce accomplished students.

In elementary through junior high school, teachers usually devote the vast majority of their energy to two distinct groups: top-performing honors students, and struggling or disruptive students. The vast majority of average students with ordinary grades and personalities are largely left to rely on self-reliance. Otherwise, why would countless families compete fiercely to get their kids into elite prestige schools?

As for every single child’s “innate genius”?

Please. Whether you seek out expensive one-on-one tutoring or foster it at home (after all, parents love cram schools anyway), do not gamble your entire future on the expectation that 95% of ordinary public school teachers will serve as legendary talent scouts.

If you genuinely want every child to receive entirely customized instruction—teaching monkeys to climb and fish to swim—the most practical option today is to pray you encounter a saintly educator dedicated to mentorship who turned down lucrative corporate salaries (and remember, even the movie Dead Poets Society was set in an elite prep school), or opt for homeschooling. Yet homeschooling not only demands extensive family resources, but also relies heavily on the breadth of the parents’ educational vision and worldview; otherwise, children remain just as trapped in hereditary socioeconomic constraints.

Finally, the short video “Teaching a Fish to Climb a Tree” also advanced a puzzling logical fallacy: the host adamantly argued that classrooms have not progressed over the past century. To that point, one might just as well debate the trivial distinctions between paper books and e-readers. (Text / Lin Ziming, Tamsui)

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account