The well-known beverage chain “Stornaway” (英國藍, British Blue) was recently exposed for using rose petals in its tea beverages contaminated with residues of 11 different pesticides and insecticides, including DDT, acephate, carbendazim, dimethoate, monocrotophos, profenofos, and isofenphos-methyl (with 13 chemicals detected in the initial round of testing). Investigations revealed that Stornaway’s raw material supplier, “Yuanyi Trading Company,” falsified certificates of origin, claiming rose petals imported from Iran were from Germany. According to the Kaohsiung City Department of Health, out of the 4,500 kilograms of rose petals originally imported by Yuanyi, over a thousand kilograms had already been consumed by customers.
On the other hand, Yuanyi Trading Company claimed that the imported rose petals had earlier been submitted to SGS laboratories for testing without exceeding legal residue limits for pesticides and insecticides. They suspected that downstream distributors or individual drink shops might have blended in adulterated rose petals from unknown third parties. Relevant authorities are currently tracing the supply chain and verifying the blending of different raw material batches.
Once again, this has devolved into a familiar food safety drama where everyone—from the importers at the top of the pyramid to the middle distributors and the retail drink shops at the base—claims to be a “victim.” In the eyes of these businesses, consumers are almost never acknowledged as victims, but rather viewed as troublesome debt collectors knocking at their door. Across these recurring food safety scandals, we rarely hear sincere apologies directed toward consumers (a practice Japanese businesses handle far better).
As public outrage mounted, Stornaway announced it would compensate consumers: anyone who verbally stated they had purchased the drink would receive two complimentary cups. Yet barely two hours after issuing that statement, Stornaway amended its policy, declaring that consumers could only claim compensation by presenting empty cups [4].
I find myself wondering: what kind of person "**routinely collects takeout drink cups for fun**"???
A new Stornaway branch opened near my home not long ago. Purely because of the name, I never had any desire to patronize it (I♥UK). But back in my school days, a classmate was promoted to store manager at a well-known chain beverage franchise where they had worked part-time for two years. A group of us would often hang out at the shop to chat, picking up plenty of inside details. Furthermore, during a casual chat with a café owner [1], I heard more industry secrets about the takeout beverage business. All of this left me with little fondness for the business model behind modern bubble tea and beverage shops. That is not even mentioning a certain tea chain that, despite years of public protests, stubbornly insisted on using highly pollutant styrofoam cups—cups that can still occasionally be spotted strewn along picturesque coastlines.
Fundamentally, all floral petal products are unsafe food ingredients in my view. Maintaining petals in an aesthetically fresh and pristine condition during growth typically demands heavy chemical spraying. Moreover, the delicate and intricate geometry of petals makes post-harvest processing difficult; any slight mishap in crop management or environmental control easily leads to pesticide residues far exceeding legal limits.
Furthermore, even if an ingredient “passes inspection,” it usually only means its residue is below an arbitrary regulatory ceiling. Conversely, numerous unlisted synthetic compounds might be present without technically being non-compliant (a regulatory loophole). This is the sober reality of the modern industrial food supply.
Dewy Rose (@Anja Pietsch)
Additionally, when purchasing fresh herbs from local markets or plant nurseries, you should never cook with them right out of the pot. You never truly know what chemicals the growers sprayed on those plants. By the same token, when restaurants boast about using fresh herbs, one cannot help but worry whether those herb leaves carry concentrated residues (restaurants rarely send their herbs for lab testing).
In fact, tea leaves present a massive problem of their own. Even relatively high-priced teas grown in Taiwan often suffer from pesticide overuse. What is more alarming is how ubiquitous beverage shops manage to keep the raw cost of their brewed tea astonishingly cheap while sourcing bulk quantities of black and green tea leaves from ambiguous origins (mostly mainland China, Vietnam, Indonesia, or other Southeast Asian countries)—and yet produce a flavor that general consumers find acceptable [5]. To me, this ranks among the hundred great mysteries of Taiwan.
(Update on 2015.04.21: Shortly after writing this piece, Stornaway’s black tea was also found by the Council of Agriculture to exceed pesticide residue limits. Stornaway has since suspended operations voluntarily. If you recall the Vietnamese tea scandal, tests in the middle of last year found pesticide levels exceeding standards by 27 times, yet Taiwan imports over 20,000 metric tons of Vietnamese tea annually. Evidently, industry players have learned zero lessons—though there is hardly any deterrent given how ridiculously light the penalties are.)
Although the human body possesses a remarkable capability to metabolize unwanted substances, that does not mean we should willingly ingest an onslaught of chemical cocktails. The modern food industry has brought to life a cynical reality: "**My body is your chemical plant.**"
News reports frequently cite how harmful Coca-Cola is to the body, claiming it can strip rust or clean toilets. Yet that phenomenon is primarily driven by the mild acidity of carbonated water. Aside from its proprietary flavor formula, Coke’s nutritional information and ingredients are clearly disclosed to the public.
By contrast, everyday street-side beverage stalls never print their complete ingredient formulations on their cups. Most customers haven’t the faintest idea what chemical agents have gone into the tea or fruit drink they are sipping. From my observations, the aroma and sweetness in nearly all takeout tea and fruit beverages are concocted using flavored powders, syrups, or concentrated gels, with base tea boiled in backroom vats—heaven only knows how these cheap industrial chemical concoctions are manufactured.
Takeout beverage shops have always been an extraordinarily high-margin industry, where profits can multiply wholesale costs many times over. Several beverage founders have even expanded into global franchises. Yet while chasing sky-high profits, how many business owners would hold their products to the standard: “Would I bravely drink this myself?” I do not know the answer. Perhaps health was never entered as a variable in their beverage-making equations.
Conversely, is Coke genuinely that terrible? Perhaps, given that many of its ingredients aren’t particularly beneficial [6], its sugar content is sky-high, and you can’t ask the convenience store clerk to reduce the sweetness [2]. Even sugar-free diet sodas rely on artificial sweeteners that carry their own health questions. If evaluated strictly by healthiness and manufacturing hygiene, boiled plain water easily beats mass-produced bottled Coca-Cola (or similar beverages), yet both are vastly superior to street takeout beverage stands that involve complex, multi-tiered transport and unstandardized manual handling (which in turn beat open night market drink stalls).
Unfortunately, regular municipal boiled water in cities often tastes flat and uninspiring, which even I dislike. I once drank fresh meltwater from mountain snowdrifts pumped directly from pristine underground aquifers abroad; that was the first time I realized how revitalizing natural water can taste—one cup leaves you craving another! In truth, Taiwan’s beverage market still holds a vast, untapped frontier waiting for innovative resources. As for what that is, let me keep it under wraps for now; perhaps fifty years from now I might venture into the food industry (just joking).
Finally, many commentators and media outlets frequently treat bubble tea and takeout drink stalls as a proud emblem of “Taiwanese identity.” I have always found this amusingly absurd. It reminds me of the iconic British dish (food, not haute cuisine) “Fish & Chips”: after eating at seven or eight shops operated separately by white locals and Chinese immigrants, one immediately notices dramatic contrasts in management, décor, and kitchen sanitation. Perhaps the fault never lies in the food itself, but in the reckless pursuit of quick profits.
Icy Rock Brook (@William Doyle)
P.S. Only after finishing did I realize this commentary wasn’t short at all!
Further Reading
- Coffee Entrepreneurship: A casual chat at “Faery Tale Coffee” near Taipei Main Station.
- Healthy Diet: How much sugar is in your drinks?
- 8 Safe Drinking Water Tips: Demystifying Bottled Water, Mineral Water, and Tap Water.
- On April 17, Stornaway issued a third statement clarifying that besides presenting empty cups, customers who purchased after March 1 could receive two compensation drinks by recounting the approximate purchase time and store location, provided the transaction matched POS records.
- The single best-tasting takeout tea shop I have ever encountered was directly opposite Jiji Train Station in Jiji Township, Nantou County. The shop claimed to source local Taiwan Tea No. 8 (Assam black tea) from Lugu or Yuchih. Even its basic black tea possessed an intoxicating aroma and rich, velvety mouthfeel, outclassing every other drink shop across Taiwan. After Miss Miaobai introduced me to it, I became an instant regular.
- Since numerous medical studies report conflicting conclusions regarding the actual long-term bodily impact of cola beverages, we refrain from dwelling on contentious clinical debates.
Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights
Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.
Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.
Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account




Comments