Ever since the advent of e-books, the existence of physical books has faced severe tests. In particular, following Amazon’s launch in Mainland China, the convenience of purchasing domestic and international books online (such as the Amazon Books Section and Apple iBooks Store) increased dramatically, heightening concerns among publishing insiders.
Fortunately, people have consistently maintained strong reading habits, and the tactile and visual experience of reading paper books remains far superior to e-books, leading to a dynamic balancing act in the physical book market.
Still, the sense of crisis sparked by e-books remains constantly on the minds of publishers. When the Taipei Public Library announced a service allowing readers to reserve books online and pick them up at convenience stores, it prompted publishing industry figures to demand the implementation of Public Lending Rights (PLR).
Wang Cheng-hui, Vice Chairman of the Taipei Publishers and Book Distributors Association, suggested that the government could look to countries like the United Kingdom and France, where the government pays compensation to authors and publishing houses for every library book borrowed.
Wang pointed out that tax exemptions for books would serve as a powerful booster for the book market. However, other industries might also want to follow suit, which is why dozens of public hearings on this topic have previously ended without resolution.
He noted that with the governing party holding complete legislative and executive control, “it ultimately comes down to whether the government has the determination to rescue the book market.” For instance, to protect bookstores three years ago, Mainland China exempted the wholesale and retail book sector from a 13% value-added tax, yielding notable positive results.
Publishers facing an increasingly quiet market have proposed several solutions to the government in recent years, including granting book publishers a 5% business tax exemption comparable to magazine publishers, tax deductions for book purchases, and advancing public lending rights.
As for the Fixed Book Price (FBP) system, which has been under discussion by the Ministry of Culture since the days of the Council for Cultural Affairs, opinions remain divided across the industry, making short-term implementation difficult.
Debate over fixed book pricing has persisted for years. A study conducted by National Chengchi University commissioned by the Ministry of Culture showed that in countries where fixed pricing was introduced, the book market typically experienced an initial contraction that took years to ease; if implemented in Taiwan, there would likely be a similar period of adjustment and growing pains.
Wang Jung-wen, Chairman of Yuan-Liou Publishing Co., argued that the book market could hardly get any worse, suggesting that bold action should be taken so publishers would no longer inflate list prices to offset steep retailer discounts. This would allow independent and brick-and-mortar bookstores to earn reasonable profits and create a sustainable ecosystem.
In response to industry recommendations, the Ministry of Culture stated that the book purchase tax deduction proposal has been commissioned to the Chung-Hua Institution for Economic Research for evaluation and will serve as policy reference after review. Regarding issues such as public lending rights, library procurement mechanisms, and business tax exemptions for book publishing, the ministry has urged the publishing industry to jointly establish a dedicated research task force to prepare legislative proposals. Meanwhile, the study on fixed book pricing is also being reviewed, after which public hearings will be held to determine subsequent policy directions.
Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights
Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.
Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.
Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account



Comments