While riding the local monorail on a recent trip to Okinawa, a question suddenly crossed my mind: “Are passengers allowed to eat inside these train cars?” The question arose because back home on the Taipei Metro (MRT) and city buses, we have been conditioned so strictly (the ban in the MRT applies from the moment you tap past the fare gates). The rationale behind such restrictions, beyond preventing the broken windows effect, also stems from administrative convenience and lowering cleaning costs.

So when our group boarded the monorail carriages, determined to represent our homeland with impeccable manners, we stood frozen in disciplined silence (though partly because we ran out of topics to chat about).

In fact, across Japan—whether on the Shinkansen, regular trains, monorails, subways, taxis, Uber, or city buses—there is no statutory law explicitly prohibiting eating or drinking.

Delicious Gratin (Photo by Lin Jin-Liang)

Transit operators even install tempting vending machines right on station platforms (including ice cream vending machines!).

However, in Japanese social norms, consuming full meals or drinking alcohol conspicuously in shared public transit is traditionally regarded as poor manners. Outside of occasional retirees, hardly anyone does so on local commuter lines (and truthfully, I prefer to avoid it as well).

What I observed in the carriages were quiet students and salarymen, either sitting or standing peacefully, alongside restless foreign tourists (us)—with no sign of the legendary beer-guzzling salarymen or passengers gorging on heavy meals.

Furthermore, universal courtesies apply anywhere in the world: on the condition of not inconveniencing others, foods with strong odors should be conscientiously avoided, and rowdy intoxication is unacceptable.

Speaking of which, I am reminded of an intriguing contrast between Japan and Taiwan.

In Japan, passengers can discreetly eat snacks or drink beverages on trains, but speaking on mobile phones is strictly avoided; in Taiwan, speaking loudly on a phone on public transit is strangely tolerated, yet taking a sip of water or eating a snack is strictly penalized with fines.

This contrast is genuinely thought-provoking. Back home, basic physiological needs are restricted by rigid rules, yet noise disturbance from loud phone conversations is largely dismissed as a private matter—if you find it noisy, you are expected to confront the speaker yourself.

Everyday public life in Taiwan often carries a manufactured sense of guilt, readily amplified by social policing. Consequently, priority seating becomes hyper-scrutinized, total eating and drinking bans are enforced throughout stations, and behavioral constraints proliferate.

“Overcorrecting to the point of absurdity”—that idiom came to mind. When commuters are penalized even for sipping water on a commute, it feels as though everyday autonomy has been pushed too far into over-regulation (or is that being overly critical?).

Early Bookings for Japanese Minshuku & Hotels: Discount Accommodation Information.

✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account