A viral video recently made the rounds on Facebook concerning a father overseas who, upon discovering that his toddler had held a young puppy underwater until it drowned, felt the child needed severe discipline—and proceeded to violently hurl the toddler into a deep swimming pool.
The father was subsequently arrested by local police and formally prosecuted in court. The critical issue that sparked widespread outrage? The child was only two years old!
Predictably, online comment boards ignited into two fierce camps. One faction argued that the father’s harsh punishment was well-deserved, claiming a toddler must be made to understand the sanctity of life at all costs. The opposing camp maintained that a two-year-old child has no concept of morality or mortality; subjecting such a fragile toddler to this degree of punishment was pure abuse, and at most, gentle redirection was all that was called for.
The former perspective holds merit in that children truly do need to learn the value of living beings. In reality, I have seen far too many parents who lack this awareness themselves; how could anyone expect their children to be properly guided under such care?
At the same time, I share the latter group’s horror: the father’s retaliation was indefensibly extreme. Even in the heat of blind rage or a momentary loss of control, nobody should ever violently throw a two-year-old child—whose skeletal and muscular systems are still delicate and forming—high through the air into water.
Yet I cannot fully subscribe to the second camp’s defense either.
Through spending time with young children, I have found that they simply fail to comprehend that living creatures can perish permanently (an outcome we adults recognize as tragic). Illuminating this boundary is fundamentally the responsibility of adults.
Chalking whether a child can grasp something entirely up to age is a deeply flawed cop-out. It is no different from shrugging off cruelty by arguing that because humans sit atop the food chain, taking the lives of other species carries zero moral weight.
That rationale is completely broken.
Consider a simple illustration: when a two-year-old is happily licking an ice cream cone, what happens if you abruptly snatch it away and throw it into the trash can right before their eyes?
More than half of toddlers will freeze in confusion for a second, and then burst into heartbroken tears.
Loss, separation, and permanent disappearance are foundational pillars of life education. Only when young minds grasp the irreversibility of loss do they begin learning to cherish what is in front of them.
How to guide a toddler toward learning this lesson constructively depends entirely on how parents educate and communicate in daily life.
Children discover the wider world through the windows we open for them. (Credits: Jinliang Lin)
A two-year-old child might not possess an abstract philosophical concept of why holding a puppy underwater is considered deeply "wrong" by adults, but they are acutely perceptive of how you respond to their actions. Toddlers at this stage are in one of the most receptive learning phases of development.
If you treat severe harm with the exact same mild tap on the hand you give when they sneak an extra cookie before dinner, why would you expect them not to repeat the behavior? Consequently, the child misses the opportunity to learn how to coexist respectfully with other living creatures.
Still, under no circumstances should an adult ever throw a toddler into a pool. Keep that firmly in mind.
Reader Q&A
What should you do when a partner loses control and violently hurls a child into water? (Reader Bline)
Reader Bline commented:
Absolutely! If I were that mother, after rescuing my child from the pool, I would have kicked that husband straight into the deep end right after him!
Author’s Response:
Haha, I completely empathize with the visceral urge to kick a reckless partner straight into the pool!
A two-year-old holding a puppy underwater happens because their cognitive framework has not yet developed the irreversible concept of death; bridging that understanding requires patient, consistent parental guidance through daily life. Yet this father used his overwhelming physical power as an adult to fling a fragile, developing toddler into a pool. That was not education—it was sheer venting of adult rage and unadulterated domestic abuse!
In the everyday reality of parenting, an ignorant child is far less dangerous than an emotionally immature partner who throws violent tantrums at the first sign of trouble. If the mother had kicked her out-of-control husband into the water after rescuing her toddler, it would simply have been poetic justice—"giving him a firsthand taste of drowning terror" (chuckles). In real life, however, establishing firm boundaries and calm, rational communication protocols remains the paramount duty for safeguarding your child’s physical and psychological well-being.
Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights
Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.
Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.
Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account



Comments