Because many of my Facebook connections are literary scholars and writers, debates over the proportion of Classical Chinese in the high school curriculum have been filling my timeline lately. Some lean toward slashing the ratio, but far more hope to “at least” maintain the existing ratio (meaning they dare not dream of asking for more).

The curriculum review committee’s decision came out today, concluding that the original proportion would be maintained. Consequently, public attention shifted toward the curriculum review committee itself, where nearly one-third of the voting members opted to abstain.

Advocates of Classical Chinese condemned the abstainers; opponents condemned the abstainers just as fiercely.

While the fence-sitting abstainers became the target of ridicule from both sides, in my view, they fully deserve the criticism.

If you don’t have the courage to take a stand, why bother sitting on the committee like Latisha Chan hogging the toilet stall without finishing business[1]?

I personally do not have a strong obsession over whether the percentage of Classical Chinese is tweaked down. But by that standard, I might as well ask: can we reduce the proportion of mathematics in the curriculum? While I regularly scored 100 in geometry, my algebra was atrocious—usually only scraping 59 thanks to teacher mercy.

So, since pocket calculators exist, why spend years learning arithmetic operations by hand!?

Since algebra is rarely used in daily grocery shopping, why waste time learning abstract algebra!?

And while we’re at it, since very few people actually uphold civic virtues anyway, why not abolish civics and ethics altogether?

Although these rhetorical questions sound bitterly sarcastic and downright ridiculous (typical internet banter), lowering the proportion of Classical Chinese out of politically motivated correctness essentially strangles our cultural literacy and our fundamental aesthetic ability to interpret beauty through language!

Being unable to read, comprehend, or appreciate the subtle genius of Classical Chinese is not your fault, nor is it proof of the absurd claim that Classical Chinese is an outdated relic. Rather, it reflects the inadequacy of the Chinese language teachers who taught you! They failed to guide you into appreciating the beauty of language; they failed to help you envision the clash of intellect and soul ancient writers underwent as they condensed boundless wisdom into elegant phrases. What a profound pity to discard all that!

Even if we grow into adults who have little leisure time to delve into ancient texts, what we absorb during our formative years becomes woven into our cognitive pathways, providing spiritual nourishment for future growth.

Just now I saw a media article headlined “Too Much Classical Chinese Makes Children Suffer,” claiming that high ratios of classical texts put entire classrooms of kids to sleep, concluding that classical texts should be cut. Is this borderline-absurd logic truly the beacon of the vernacular-only movement? If so, math puts whole classrooms to sleep far more reliably—so shouldn’t math be cut first?

Even taking ten thousand steps back, fundamental primary and secondary education is designed precisely to expose students to varied disciplines so they can discover what they love and specialize in it later.

References
  1. Brighten Life / Some Thoughts on Latisha Chan’s Heat-Illness Withdrawal from the Universiade to Compete in the US Open.
  2. Opening High School Classical Chinese Curriculum to Online Voting to Drastically Slash Its Ratio Is Plain Stupidity
  3. Classical Chinese Is Exquisite and Beautiful; Those Wasting Time Debating Its Abolition Are Either Foolish or Malicious!
  4. The Absurd Fallacy of “High School Students Disappointed by Classical Chinese Curriculum” | Liberty Times Study 2017.09.11
✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account