At 10:34 AM, I received an SMS from CTBC Bank stating: “CTBC message valid for this transaction only. Please verify webpage identification code OON, enter OTP password 9999999, verify last 4 digits of card number 6288, amount $16,890.0”[1]. The sender’s number was 0911510275; a Google search yielded no disclosed records or reports regarding that number.

This banking SMS left me completely baffled. Setting aside who has time to browse online shopping sites at 10:30 on a weekday morning, the amount cited was nearly twenty thousand dollars. This motivated me to willingly and quickly call CTBC for the very first time.

Of course, it wasn’t until nearly 11:30 AM that I actually remembered to make the call (Inner voice: “Wait! Didn’t you say it was urgent and needed immediate attention!?”). However, as long as you bypass their toll-free number[2], getting through to a CTBC customer service representative is actually quite fast.

This time, the person on the other end was male, and his voice was anything but sweet or soothing (this is not a sweet customer service rep, this is not a sweet customer service rep, this is not a sweet customer service rep ─── repeating three times because it’s important, not sure where I picked up that habit).

CTBC Bank Credit Card Transaction OTP MessageFigure 1: CTBC transaction verification SMS.

After listening to me recite the full SMS text, the representative checked his terminal and told me: “Mr. Kung, this verification SMS belongs to someone else.”

“Why would someone else’s SMS be sent to my mobile phone?” I asked, full of confusion, to this representative whose voice wasn’t gentle at all and clearly wished to wrap up the call quickly.

The rep replied: “Another credit card holder previously entered the wrong phone number. We will contact the cardholder and request that they update their telephone number.”

“So you are certain this has absolutely nothing to do with my own credit card transactions?”

“Yes, you don’t need to worry at all,” the representative said quite firmly, which brought me considerable relief.

Next came the marketing pitch from this far-from-melodious representative (trying to push insurance policies, installment loan promotions, and the like). After I swiftly brushed him off, I hung up the phone.

Only after hanging up did it suddenly hit me: “Ah, I forgot to tell him to notify me for a follow-up once the update is confirmed.”

Beyond reminding me of recent Chunghwa Telecom micropayment verification scams, this incident made me wonder: which fool developed CTBC’s personal data management system?

I cannot fathom how a system so intimately tied to fund security and transaction integrity ─── especially one tasked with authenticating transaction safety ─── lacks even a basic data verification step, resulting in one-time passwords being dispatched haphazardly to incorrect numbers. And this supposedly low-probability error happened right to me. No wonder news reports frequently spotlight unauthorized charges, fraud syndicates, and internal security loopholes being exploited.

Or could it be that my phone number was genuinely compromised for illicit activities? All sorts of doubts lingered in my mind. It seems I will only know for sure once the next billing statement arrives.

Further Reading:
  1. 16,890 is an unusually specific figure that piqued my curiosity. After a quick Google search, I suspect this gentleman (or lady) purchased the Canon EOS M + 22mm + 18-55mm + EF-M adapter bundle ─── and the product listing currently shows it as sold out (oh my).
  2. CTBC Customer Service Hotline: 02-27458080. Toll-free number: 0800-024-365 (landlines ONLY ─── just venting about mobile phones being unable to dial it).
✦ Independent Journalism · Reader Support ✦

Support Independent Perspectives & In-Depth Insights

Every thoughtful analysis and candid critique comes from our dedication to truth and quality. We choose not to follow sensational algorithms or clickbait headlines.

Sustaining independent research requires reader support. Make a one-time or monthly contribution, securely processed by Google.

Payments secured by Google · Manage or cancel anytime in your Google Account